AITAH for arresting my boyfriend's brother during a traffic stop?

LushiePetalKiss 1280 comments

In the heart of a quiet night, Lucy, a dedicated police officer, faced a wrenching test of loyalty and duty.

Years of hard work had shaped her into a woman who upheld justice without bias, but that night, the line between personal ties and professional integrity blurred painfully when she pulled over her boyfriend’s brother for a serious offense.

Confronted with Sam’s reckless disregard for the law and his own safety, Lucy stood firm, even as his accusations pierced her resolve.

In that charged moment, she embod*ed the harsh truth that sometimes, doing what’s right means breaking the bonds of family and facing the storm of betrayal head-on.

AITAH for arresting my boyfriend's brother during a traffic stop?
‘AITAH for arresting my boyfriend's brother during a traffic stop?’

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Get the latest stories delivered to your inbox.

A Wave of Opinions Just Hit the Thread:

It didn’t take long before the comment section turned into a battleground of strong opinions and even stronger emotions.

The original poster firmly stands by her professional duty to arrest her boyfriend's brother for a DUI, viewing it as necessary for public safety, which directly conflicts with her boyfriend's desire for her to prioritize family leniency over strict adherence to the law.

Was the officer justified in upholding the law and ensuring public safety by arresting a family member for a clear DUI, or should she have considered the potential long-term damage to her personal relationships by refusing to look the other way in a situation where no accident had yet occurred?