AITA for telling my neighbour to get over it when I wake her baby up?
In a quiet neighborhood, a man walks the tightrope of consideration, trying to balance his life with the delicate needs of a new mother and her baby next door.
His garage lies just meters from their bedroom, and though his roller door beeps softly upon arrival, he has gone out of his way to muffle every sound, even silencing his beloved drums and refusing social gatherings, all in the hope of preserving peace.
Yet, despite his efforts, tension brews as the demands of safety and security clash with the fragile quiet the baby requires.
When asked to delay parking his car late at night due to noise, he faces an impossible choice—between protecting his prized vehicle from thieves and respecting the neighbor’s plea—unfolding a silent struggle where empathy, fear, and frustration collide in the stillness of the night.
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Get the latest stories delivered to your inbox.
The original poster (OP) feels they have made significant sacrifices regarding noise levels to accommodate their new neighbors and their baby, leading to a sense of frustration and a decision to stop compromising.
The central conflict is between the OP's right to use their property (including parking their car securely and playing music at reasonable hours) and the neighbors' expectation that the OP should adhere to stricter quiet hours due to their infant's sleep schedule.
Given the escalation from a quiet garage door beep to blocking a driveway, where does the responsibility for maintaining neighborly peace lie when one party feels they have already made substantial concessions while the other seems to demand absolute silence?
Is the OP justified in ceasing all voluntary noise restrictions, or is there a middle ground that respects both property rights and the neighbor's urgent need for sleep?
When the Crowd Speaks, It Echoes Loudly:
The thread exploded with reactions. Whether agreeing or disagreeing, everyone had something to say — and they said it loud.