My boyfriend is giving me the silent treatment because I made a joke about his size
The original poster (OP) and her boyfriend were preparing dinner together in a lighthearted atmosphere. While handing out plates, the boyfriend asked the OP how large a portion of scallop potatoes she wanted.
The OP responded by saying, "not too big but not too small," and then jokingly added, "just like you." The boyfriend immediately reacted negatively, stating the comment was rude and expressing anger.
Despite the OP apologizing and explaining that the comment was not meant as an insult, the boyfriend pulled away when she attempted to hug him.
The core issue for the OP is whether her brief, joking comment truly warranted such a strong, sustained negative reaction, leaving her unsure of her actions.
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Get the latest stories delivered to your inbox.
The OP is facing a significant conflict because her casual, joking remark was interpreted by her boyfriend as a direct insult, leading to him shutting down emotionally and physically.
The central tension lies between the OP's belief that the comment was harmless banter and the boyfriend's deep offense, which he has demonstrated by refusing communication and affection.
The reader must consider whether the boyfriend's extreme overreaction is a sign of underlying sensitivity or insecurity, or if the OP failed to recognize a boundary regarding comments about his size or performance.
The final question is whether the OP was the a*shole for making the comment, or if the boyfriend's subsequent silent treatment is an unreasonable response to a minor joke.
From Supportive to Savage: The Crowd Responds:
What started as a simple post quickly turned into a wildfire of opinions, with users chiming in from all sides.