AITAH for not wanting my wife and mother-in-law to keep reminding me to “keep my voice down” before every family gathering?
The user, a 45-year-old man whose parents are deceased, relies on his wife's family (including his 36-year-old wife) for family gatherings.
For many years, he felt like an outsider due to his father-in-law's disapproval and strained relations with his mother-in-law over religious differences.
A shift occurred when the user felt genuinely included at a Thanksgiving dinner after having a few drinks and participating fully.
However, this feeling was quickly undone when his wife warned him about being too loud due to her father's migraines, followed immediately by a text from his mother-in-law reiterating the same request.
This double correction left the user feeling rejected and embarra*sed, leading him to withdraw during the subsequent Christmas gathering and reverting to feeling like an outsider.
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Get the latest stories delivered to your inbox.
The core conflict for the user is the ongoing tension between his genuine desire to participate and feel accepted by his in-laws, and the repeated preemptive behavioral policing he receives regarding his volume.
He feels that the repeated warnings, especially from his wife and mother-in-law, prioritize his father-in-law's comfort over his sense of inclusion, causing him significant resentment and suppressing his willingness to engage.
The question remains whether the user is being overly sensitive to a valid concern regarding the father-in-law's health needs, or if the family, particularly the wife and mother-in-law, are employing an overly intrusive and counterproductive m**hod of boundary enforcement that actively prevents his integration. Is the consistent pre-event policing fair, or is it guaranteeing his alienation?
A Wave of Opinions Just Hit the Thread:
This one sparked a storm. The comments range from brutally honest to surprisingly supportive — and everything in between.