AITA for refusing to donate my kidney to my estranged father who abandoned me as a child?
The story centers on a 28-year-old woman (OP) whose biological father left her and her mother when she was five years old. This father established a new family and maintained no contact, offering no financial or emotional support over the years.
Recently, the OP was contacted unexpectedly by her father's current wife, who informed her that the father is critically ill and requires a kidney transplant.
The wife stated that the OP is the best medical match and pleaded with her to undergo testing. The OP immediately refused, citing the decades of abandonment and lack of a relationship, feeling no obligation to undergo major surgery for a stranger.
Following this refusal, the OP has been heavily criticized by her father's extended family, who call her selfish, while even her own mother suggests she reconsider to avoid future guilt.
The central dilemma for the OP is whether her decision to prioritize her past trauma and lack of relationship over his urgent medical need is too harsh.
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
No spam, unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy
The Internet Sounded Off — and It Got Loud:
Support, sarcasm, and strong words — the replies covered it all. This one definitely got people talking.
The OP is facing a severe conflict between her established emotional boundaries and the intense pressure from her father's family and even her mother.
Her refusal stems from the deep-seated feelings of abandonment caused by her father's total withdrawal during her formative years.
While she feels justified in not repaying years of neglect, she is now grappling with external accusations of being heartless and the potential weight of future guilt if her father dies.
The core question remains whether a biological tie, coupled with a life-saving need, overrides the complete absence of a parental relationship and the emotional damage inflicted by abandonment.
Readers must weigh the value of personal autonomy and justified resentment against the moral expectation to offer aid in a life-or-death situation, especially when facing criticism for self-preservation.