UPDATE – AITAH for telling my girlfriend I can’t trust her anymore when it comes to her wanting a baby?

In the quiet spaces between their shared moments, a hidden pain festered—a yearning for attention and validation that felt elusive from her own family. Her choice to fabricate a miscarriage was not born from malice but from a deep, aching loneliness that demanded to be seen and felt. The silence she maintained was a shield against the vulnerability of truth, a desperate plea for connection in a world that seemed indifferent.

He stood at a crossroads, torn between love and honesty, grappling with the raw reality that the woman he cared for was drowning in her own sorrow. The fragile threads of their relationship trembled as he confronted the painful truth, knowing that without open dialogue, the foundation between them could not survive. In that moment, the weight of unspoken emotions threatened to unravel everything they had built.

UPDATE - AITAH for telling my girlfriend I can’t trust her anymore when it comes to her wanting a baby?

Firstly, for some context, we have a planned parenthood that specializes in abortions like 5 minutes away. I understand people thinking she didn’t want to get an abortion because of protesters.

I completely understand. I drive by that specific place every single day for work. I have seen no protesters. It’s usually empty besides a few cars on the side of the side of the road.

But, I still understand why she wouldn’t want a medical abortion from reading the comments.

I asked her why, what was her goal here. She was trying really hard to avoid the conversation and left the room but (I apologize if this makes me an asshole) but I told her if we can’t have a conversation about this I have to end the relationship.

She came back in and said the reason why she did this was because she never felt like her family gave her enough attention in life, and didn’t feel supported by them so she wanted to tell them she had a miscarriage so they can feel bad for her.

I was confused because she could’ve just gotten a medical abortion and lied about it instead of just harming her body with a toxic herb. I asked her about that, and she told me she wanted to have the experience of having an actual miscarriage.

I was so confused and in shock so I didn’t say much else because all of this just sounded crazy to me. She told me she didn’t want me mad at her and she doesn’t want to break up and she was literally begging me to not break up with her.

I asked her, is there any chance the baby wouldn’t have been mine? She said no.

I told her she needs to get therapy ASAP. I thankfully make enough to afford therapy and I told her I will pay for her if she just please go to therapy. She agreed. I also told her she needs to go to the hospital and I was telling her all of your comments about the septic that can happen and liver and kidney damage and that kinda scared her into going to the hospital to get checked out.

We went to the hospital last night and thankfully she is ok. Apparently she drank around 1 cup of it a day for a few days. I found out she was also taking some other things (high dose of vitamin c, turmeric, parsley).

That’s pretty much it for now, but I’m not too sure where to go from here. I love her and I do want to be with her but all of this is so out of the blue. Thanks for all of the comments on the last post.

If anything else happens I’ll make another update.

Here’s how people reacted:

evil-mouse

My man, are **YOU** Okay??

This was your child too. And you don’t seen to react to the fact that she did this to your child. You need to in touch with a grief counselor. For yourself.

Yes you have been reacting to the situation, but not to the lose of your child yet. If that grief is not handled correctly it will come at you like a bat out of hell. You will be hit with the feeling of lose all of a sudden.

She needs help, because what she did was unhinged, but you can’t be there for her if you yourself break down completely, and that is where you are heading if you don’t allow yourself to grief.

Stay with her or break up, that is a decision you need to make yourself, but you have to be in the right state of mind to do that.

She is getting the help she needs, now it is time for you to get the help you need.

throwitaway3857

You’re sweet for being caring and supportive. But when she’s healed, you need to leave. She doesn’t get to determine whether yall stay together or break up. You do bc YOU are the one betrayed.

She purposely tried to harm herself to get rid of the baby instead of doing it the safe way. That’s mental illness right there.

You can’t trust her to not harm your future children “just to get attention and sympathy”. There’s a mom who was on the news for that. Years ago. I think she killed 4 of them bc I think one survived.

What are you going to do when she goes after your 7 or 13 year old? It’s one thing to want an abortion bc you don’t want children. It’s a psycho thing to pretend to miscarry to get sympathy.

Run OP. Run.

bloomerhen

This is batshit crazy. I’m pro-choice when there’s a legitimate reason not to have a child but not as an attention-seeking stunt? What the actual fuck.

You wanted this child? You’re ok with her killing it for family attention? You’re more concerned about her idiotic ingestion of toxic herbs (oh great, you’re also dating a moron) than her making a decision to terminate YOUR child for her own selfish purposes?

Her behaviour is sociopathic and dangerous. She lied, she ended a developing baby that she claimed she wanted for attention by poisoning herself, what else will she do to get what she feels she deserves? Run.

Careful-Bumblebee-10

>She came back in and said the reason why she did this was because she never felt like her family gave her enough attention in life, and didn’t feel supported by them so she wanted to tell them she had a miscarriage so they can feel bad for her.

Yikes.

>I asked her about that, and she told me she wanted to have the experience of having an actual miscarriage.

Holy FUCK YIKES.

There’s something drastically wrong with your girlfriend. This is beyond reasonable, normal, or acceptable. She needs help NOW and you need to decide if you want to continue this relationship. This is a whole other level of disturbing.

BlueGreen_1956

YIKES!

This woman is mentally ill. You need to get far away from her as fast as you can.

She induced a miscarriage to GET ATTENTION.

I know attention whores will do many things to get their fix, but there has to be a limit.

Wearing a thong bikini with your entire ass hanging out to get attention is one thing but what she did has to cross over the line.

While what she did was despicable and disgusting, the silver lining is that you will not have to deal with her for the next 18 years.

Do NOT have a baby with her.

And remember, never stick your dick in crazy.

AlphabetSoup51

First: Your gf needs serious psychological help. That is such incredibly dangerous behavior. It is very kind of you to support her in that.

Second: I am so sorry this happened to you. That was YOUR potential child, and she aborted it … for attention. That is just abhorrent.

Given the scenario, I hope that YOU will also seek some counseling to work through this for yourself. You need to take a really deep look at this relationship and your future and determine whether this is the partner for you.

Best of luck to you. I hope you both get the support you need.

ThrowAwayUser06

She sounds like she has some serious mental health issues like others have said. If you choose to stay then I would be cautious moving forward having kids with her. She’s willing to cause herself self-harm for the sake of attention. There is no telling what she would do if you guys have already had the child. I’ve seen mothers fake there child’s illness for attention before. She comes off as deeply troubled and manipulative. I don’t think she wants to hurt anyone out of malice but it’s still very concerning. If you stay, therapy is a must.
Kiefy-McReefer

Dude.

Very pro abortion here – but y’all agreed to have a baby and she killed it for sympathy and attention.

How close is that to Munchausen? If you have a child with this lunatic what’s it gonna take for her to poison her child to get more sympathy? A pin drop? What about a dead husband? That gets a lot of sympathy and attention.

She does need therapy, she also needs consequences, and under no circumstances should you reproduce with this person.

It would be deeply irresponsible, and quite frankly dangerous.

Fickle-Vegetable961

Munchausen syndrome (factitious disorder imposed on self) is when someone tries to get attention and sympathy by falsifying, inducing, and/or exaggerating an illness. They lie about symptoms, sabotage medical tests (like putting blood in their urine),

or harm themselves to get the symptoms.

Diagnosing and treating Munchausen syndrome is difficult because of the person’s dishonesty.

Ambroisie_Cy

* She is putting her body in precarious situations to get attention from her family.
* By doing this, she only thought of herself and how she could get maximum attention from everyone. She didn’t care if she was causing you pain.
* She wanted to suffer a miscarriage so she could victimise herself in front of others.

I’m no psychologist, but this sounds like HPD or Munchausen syndrome.

United-Manner20

So here’s the thing, they would have given her plenty of attention during her pregnancy and when she had the baby. It’s way more likely that she was jealous that the baby would get more attention than she would. Please do not reproduce with this person. She wanted attention from her family for a day or two the attention she and her unborn child would received. Has she simply had them.
FadingOptimist-25

It’s up to you whether you stay with her or not, but ABSOLUTELY DO NOT HAVE CHILDREN WITH HER. Use condoms, get a vasectomy, something.

My firstborn was in a toxic relationship. I told my kid that it’s okay to still love them and to feel sad about not being together, but you need to take care of yourself and your needs too. You can love someone and the relationship doesn’t work.

dreamyyteen

Damn, this situation is wild. I get that you were looking out for her, but it’s a lot to deal with. Honestly, therapy is a must for her. It’s good she’s okay, but that’s a red flag. If she’s really serious about changing and getting help, you might have to think long-term. Just make sure you’re taking care of yourself too, fam.
Outside-Factor3117

She killed a child for attention. Not for health reasons or ethical/ moral reasons. And she did it in a painful dangerous way for added sympathy. All for attention because she didn’t receive enough growing up. That is a whole ‘nother level of crazy. YTA if you stay. What will she do if you stop paying attention to her?
haddierunner

I…..have no words for this. As someone who WANTED a baby and unfortunately had a few losses in different ways, this is just off the rails insane. Absolutely insane.

If you’re able to move past this, more power to you. I would never be able to not question her again; not just about kids, but literally everything.

InfamousCup7097

So when you do have a baby with this person and she smothers it in it’s sleep and claims its sids so she cab get the attention from others during her “grieving” are you going to take partial responsibility for that actual murder or you gonna just roll with the crazy cause “you love her”?
Certain-Doughnut-216

This is crazy, she killed your child (I hope it’s really your child) to get attention from her family. What will happen if a future 5 year old child gets more attention from you than she does? Is she also going to kill him to get some attention? Honestly stay away from this crazy person 
Ilovepunkim

Dump her. She killed the baby both of you planned for attention. I’m totally agree with abortion but what she is a sociopaths. Maybe if you marry her and don’t pay her enough attention she would falsely accuse you of hitting her just to get the attention that she wants. YTA to yourself
Anna_Lou82

I am really sorry, but she needs to commited, since she is a danger to herself.

And I am sorry, a sanger to others.
She did this to get the empathy and support from her family. What if this goes away and she craves more? Another misc…. or maybe the loss of her partner…

BigPianist8326

As someone who has suffered miscarriages not my fault, fuck her. She chose to kill that baby for a fucking feeling. I’ll probably get this commented deleted anyways, but you need to get out like yesterday. What else is she going to do because she didn’t get loved enough???
AnyFeedback9609

Um… NTA… but God forbid you have a child with her and she starts poisoning them for “attention.”

What she did is literally munchausen syndrome. If you have a child I guarantee she will start munchausen syndrome by proxy. Run. Save yourself and unborn children.

MsFear

What did I just read?! I have had miscarriages and am now infertile and fuck her for wanting to experience that! SHE COULD HAVE JUST LIED AND SAID SHE WAS PREGNANT AND FAKED THAT TOO! There was no reason to go through this, she has serious mental health issues!
Proper_Rush_9367

You’re a fucking idiot for staying. We’ll read a future post of yours where you asking where it went wrong, why didn’t you see the signs etc after she completely fucks your life up and traps you with a kid.
StardewMiners

Me and my girlfriend had an accidental miscarriage like a month ago. She’s nuts please get her help. It was the worst thing we had ever been through, both personally and in our relationship
Cowabungamon

NTA. You need to get away from that as fast as possible. People who can make those kinds of jumps and logic have the potential to do anything
Friendly_Order3729

I never thought I’d hear a bad or selfish reason to have an abortion. Literally for attention!?!?

Shes a sociopath, get out while you can.

DrMoons

NTA. Also, it’s still an abortion even if it was dangerously done with herbs and self-induced. Miscarriages are spontaneous. 
NapTrapped2020

I am all for pro-choice, but this is unhinged on a clinical level.

NTA, and also, please don’t reproduce with this person.

DesperateToNotDream

She…. Wanted to have the experience of having a miscarriage?

That’s one of the most sadistic things she could have said.

GarlicAndSapphire

“the experience of having an actual miscarriage”????

What dafuq did I just read? Dude. Nope. No. Oh my. No.

WeaverofW0rlds

My original comment to your first post still stands. Get away from this woman. She is not safe to be around.
Strong_Arm8734

Not a diagnosis but she sounds like she’s at risk for munchausen syndrome. This is SERIOUS.
WiseConsequence4005

YTA if you stay, especially if you try for kids again. She did abortion for ATTENTION.
Luisguirot

There’s a saying I think you should reflect on. “Never stick your dick in the crazy”.
Gonebabythoughts

She has serious mental health issues. Do not reproduce with this person.
Fluffy-Scheme7704

So… she killed hour baby for attention and you are staying with her? YTA
unknownfena

Someone wants to experience miscarriage?? What the hell i’m reading??
Front_Quantity7001

RUN!! RUN!! 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Sircrusterson

Why are you still with this person. You need to run

Conclusion

The original poster (OP) is left grappling with a severe crisis of trust and understanding after discovering their partner intentionally induced a miscarriage using harmful herbs, motivated by a deep-seated need for attention and perceived family neglect. The central conflict lies between the OP’s desire to maintain the relationship, supported by their immediate actions to ensure her physical safety and seek professional help, and the extreme, manipulative, and self-endangering nature of the partner’s actions.

Given the partner’s demonstrated capacity for extreme deception and self-harm stemming from unmet emotional needs, the core question remains: Can a relationship survive when one partner has deliberately fabricated a life-threatening medical event for emotional validation, and what level of ongoing psychological intervention is required before trust can realistically be rebuilt?

Categories Uncategorized