AITA for telling my husband that I don’t want another child with him

For fifteen years, she weathered the storms of a marriage marked by love, pain, and relentless struggle. Despite enduring harsh words and the weight of past mistakes that never truly faded, she held on—carrying the hopes of a fragile family and the joy of their miracle daughter, a symbol of their enduring bond forged through IVF.

But beneath the surface, a silent battle raged. Her ADHD blurred the lines of daily life, turning simple tasks into sources of conflict, while the shadow of breast cancer and its unforgiving treatments drained her strength. In the quiet moments between fights and frustrations, she grappled with the harsh realities of being both vulnerable and expected to be perfect.

AITA for telling my husband that I don’t want another child with him

I (34F) have been married to my husband (37M) for almost 10 years. We’ve been together for 15 years. We have one daughter(3) through IVF. I have adhd and forget a lot of things, mainly forgetting to shut the lights off when I leave a room, which he has asked me to stop for years.

I try to remember, but occasionally forget. I’ve made progress, but he still gets frustrated.

I had breast cancer a few years ago, and the medications cause brain fog, making me forget even more. This also led to a full hysterectomy. My husband was raised with an old-school mindset regarding household roles.

He handles outside work, but in the house, he occasionally helps by moving toys for the Roomba. I work full time, then come home to cook, clean, and get our daughter ready for bed, after which she needs to cuddle until she falls asleep.

When I finish that, nothing is cleaned, and he is often sitting on the couch, sometimes having fallen asleep.

I have been asking for help around the house—sharing cooking, kitchen cleanup, and getting our daughter ready—asking that we take turns. When he agrees to a task, like dishes, it is often undone by morning.

He also creates issues about not wanting to see my family.

We recently had a large fight where he admitted he purposely doesn’t help because he is tired of reminding me to turn off the lights. He feels his years of asking about the lights outweigh my requests for help with everything else.

I am becoming very resentful.

He recently brought up surrogacy for another child. I told him I am not sure I want another child with him because he doesn’t help me. He responded that I really hurt him and that plenty of other mothers can manage everything with more than one child.

Here’s how people reacted:

Basic_Ask8109

NTA
Your husband has some red flags. He has this outdated idea that even though BOTH of you work, you’re the only one obligated to do the daily domestic chores. His chores I’m assuming are mowing the lawn, shoveling snow ( if you live somewhere that get snow), and taking out garbage/ recycling/ compost. All of those things are at most once a week or once every two weeks.
Meanwhile you have to clean( laundry, dishes, sweep, mop, bathrooms), cook( buy the groceries, prep the food, cook the meals), child care( feed and bathe daughter, read/ do night time routine and communicate with childcare provider/ school etc). Did I get that right? Sounds like you’re doing all the emotional labour in the relationship on top of most of the actual labour. Sorry pushing a button on the Roomba doesn’t qualify.
You have ADHD( often people with it are treated as though lazy even though they’re not. They just have shitty executive function). People with ADHD are always on the brink of burn out if they aren’t already.You’ve gone through IVF, pregnancy, child birth hysterectomy and cancer. FUCKING CANCER! Your husband is at best clueless, at worst he’s an absolute a- hole and narcissist. He wants to add to your list of responsibilities by having another child through a surrogate?! So he can do even less?

I don’t know if counselling is worth it. He is unlikely to change his mindset.
When engaging with him in conversation use I statements and ask questions in a curious way so as to not put him on the defensive. Example: I feel very overwhelmed and exhausted because I have to do all the house hold chores and I feel hurt when you accuse me of being lazy. It would be more fair for you to do the dishes and laundry if I’m the one cooking and grocery shopping.
You can certainly try marriage counseling as a therapist would act as a mediator and give you both tools to communicate better. Only you can decide that.

As for wanting or not wanting another child with him, you don’t have to do anything you don’t want to do. He can’t even pull his weight now with the one child you do have.

NotYourCantaloupe48

NTA Your husband calls you names…?. He insists on organizing the work load around his out-dated beliefs about marriage roles despite your frequent input that his beliefs are not working for you? He admitted he lies to placate you about chore management and so does not contribute after all. Now he is ‘hurt’ because you pointed out that his idea for a second child would unfairly add more to your already struggling workload. Rich…Your not turning off lights can be fixed by him putting motion sensors on lights–sheesh. It sounds like he prefers to weaponize it… to make you feel less. His self-centered existence might be fixable, but you might have to separate for a bit for him to understand that you are serious, and won’t be placated anymore. You need to address your growing resentment soon, too. You will feel miserable, your child will absorb that and it has no effect on your husband. He likes how things are and is working to maintain it that way….He seems to be fully benefiting (as research shows happens) from being married, while you carry almost all of the mental and emotional burden, and the personal sacrifices. This lopsided, ‘traditional’ “style” is why many married Gen-X women are not getting remarried, according to research. You need to deliberately consider and decide what your new boundaries must be (and enforce them) if you wish to stay in this one-sided marriage. ONE MORE THING. Do not believe the nonsense claim that you should stay married ‘for the children’. It can end up being more damaging, and lifelong damage.
charmaneAgedashi

1. You can’t have an old school mindset & not be an old school man . Women cooked and cleaned solo back in the day because husband paid all the bills solo that’s how it worked . If you work all day just like he does house chores should be split unless you just enjoy doing them fine . But men like this are out of their rabid mind & you have signed up for indentured servitude . You’re not a slave you’re not his slave . Let another woman be if she chooses but he needs to clean up his act . You work and pay bills that’s your house if you leave every light on in that mf it’s your prerogative . I live with my uncle who also has add or something that man also leaves the lights on in his room all the time . All the time , I just ask are you done in this room & I turn the light off & move on . I don’t get upset frustrated or annoyed & im his niece. That’s your husband ??? Yikes . I wouldn’t have another kid with him either . Smart choice .
melympia

I know reddit has a certain reputation, but have you thought about how your life would be different without your husband in it? Smaller meals to cook, 1/3 fewer dishes and less laundry, no more accusations for occasionally leaving a light on (if you even do), no more bullshit excuses for why he won’t be a partmer or a father, no more being guilt-tripped for not wanting another child… Plus you get every other weekend off (unless he won’t want your daughter anymore – he’s full enough of feces to oull that crap). On the flip side, you will have to do your own yard work.

Think about it, then think again. There is one massive AH in this story, and it isn’t you.
NTA.

Hausmannlife_Schweiz

ESH. You are an AH for saying “with him.” You are NOT an AH for saying you don’t want another child.

If living with him is that bad, then give him some time to shape up, or let him know you will leave. I was raised in an old school environment. Mom stayed at home and watched the kids Dad worked. Somehow I was able to grow enough to help my wife around the house, and have even been the stay at home husband for two different stints in our marriage. Your husband is just an A$$ don’t make excuses for him. Tell him what you need for support and get some counseling for the two of you.

Tricky-Marsupial-477

It is not clear to me from tour post, you proposed to do 50/50 on outside work and you both work equal hours for income and are planning on some kind of perfect 50/50 across the board?

It is up to couple how to handle. NAH.

Personally I am not traditional and both my parents worked but my wife got sick years ago. consequently she stopped working for an income and we had to learn a different split of responsibilities one where oner person might do 100 percent of a task, like work outside the home and the balance was the other did 100 percent of another task.

Any_Art_1364

NTA, with everything you have went through, and are still going through, he refuses to support you and then tries to justify this because you sometimes forget to turn off lights? Your husband is a pathetic, lazy, manipulative sack of shit, and his attempts to isolate you from your family and tie you down with another child are very alarming. His behaviour is already borderline abusive, is this a sign it’s escalating? I would think long and hard about what kind of life you want for yourself and your child, and exactly what he does to help you all as a family
thatplantgirl97

NTA Tell him that if he expects you to be a traditional woman, you will be quitting your job and being a full time stay at home parent. He needs to uphold his side of the tradition and financially provide. Except he won’t because he doesn’t give a shit about tradition. He just wants to control and manipulate you. This isn’t healthy or fair for you. You don’t have to live like this. Imagine how less stressful your life could be if you only had you and your child to clean after.
UnPracticed_Pagan

NTA

But you two have a lot more deeper seeded issues that you need to work on before turning into that couple that divorced after 11 years of resentment and hatred

This is beyond Reddit (who I’m sure majority will start to tell you to divorce the manchild, because he sounds like an awful partner from your perspective of what you’ve shared) – couples therapy would maybe help.

Or maybe it will tell you you need to consider more options for yourself and your child

Intelligent_Soil3419

Ask yourself do you want to wake up at 47 and still be doing the same with a 13 year old and no help, do you want to endure 10 more years of this and live to regret it. People treat you how you allow them to, you both work so you both should share the household chores. He really isn’t going to change you know this ask yourself do you want to out up with this your the only one that can answer that question.
7MillionBees

A lot of guys like the traditional mindset because it’s made to benefit them. You’re doing all the daily chores and he’s doing the ‘once in a while’ chores. Some couples like this (personally I can’t understand, it seems very unfair from my view) but if you’re unhappy he can’t just say he’s ‘old school’ and shut you down and end it there. you have to have a frank discussion about what you both expect.
alv269

NTA. This guy is a major jerk and I have to wonder why you stay with him. He doesn’t respect you, won’t help around the house, and then tries to guilt you when you won’t do what he wants. This is no way to live. You deserve better than how you’re being treated and I would venture to say that you might be less stressed and happier without him.
Crimsonfangknight

So onviosuly this isnt about the lights

You danced around it but it sounds like you had numerous emotional affairs prior
To getting married. Seems he may not have recovered from that and became resentful combined with your infertility. 

Hes being the most toxic person ever about it but it seems to me thats the source
Of all this toxicity

Plus_Cover_569

Things like this fascinates me.. You have been great all around, see you are being treated unfairly, and still question being mean. You are good hearted, but you know like I know what the answered is. You don’t deserve this and it is going to hurt, but you have to stand up for yourself.
SheepherderNo785

If he really has an “old school mindset,” then wife doing all cooking and cleaning” was also SAHM and absolutely did not work full time as well! OP NTA Worthless husband is a colossal one! Who wouldn’t seek emotional support from others? Sure aren’t getting any from him!
Ill-Novel5199

NTA, you are in a very difficult place, have too much in your plate and cannot take on anymore.

You need to take care of yourself or you will burn out. Since he won’t help, it will all be on you, there is nothing wrong with prioritizing yourself in this situation.

Inevitable_Pie9541

NTA to refuse having another child with this hostile, useless man, but why on earth have you stayed with him so long? You admit he was verbally abusive while you were *dating*… yet you married him?

You have more of a husband problem than he won’t do housework.

primordial_chaos_007

>Now he tells me that I really hurt him and that there are plenty of other mom’s out there that can do it all with more than 1 child

Have you told him that there are plenty of husbands and dads out there who actually behave as more than half a paycheck?

ceb1995

NTA, his actions make him seem like he is your second child. It’s not help you re asking for, you re asking him to be a parent, you deserve so much better. Easier said than done but I hope you are able to find some support to be rid of this man.
CJCreggsGoldfish

NTAH, and don’t cave to his bullshit manipulations blaming you. Anyone who purposefully lies to you (saying he’ll help and then doesn’t) to punish you (by giving you more work) is an asshole who doesn’t deserve more children with you.
playfulcottonwhisk

You’ve worked, mothered, cooked, cleaned, and even survived cancer, yet he still expects *you* to do more. He’s guilt-tripping you about not wanting another child when he can’t even step up for the one you already have? NTA
Middle-Fan68

You can get light switches with motion sensors. Get some in the common rooms to take away his reason for complaining. That won’t solve your husband being an AH but it’ll give him one less excuse.
ConsistentEmployee57

He expects you to carry all the mental and physical load of the household while he lounges around, then gets upset when you don’t want to add more to your plate? That’s ridiculous. NTA.
Adventurous-Day7469

NTA and I would take it a step farther than that. I would flat out tell him not only will you not have another child, unless he starts pulling his weight, you want a divorce too.
Correct-Money6124

>”Other moms do it all with more than one kid”

yeah, and a lot of them are miserable, exhausted, and stuck in unhealthy marriages. Don’t let him guilt-trip you. NTA.

Prettynikisha

You’re already a married single mother with a husband sized child. Your workload would probably be significantly lower is he were out of the picture. Consider leaving.
NervousAd7170

NTA sounds like a real manly man (by the way not a compliment) it also sounds like you are doing yourself a favor in not adding another child into an unhappy family.
SoCalThrowAway7

> Before we got engaged I’ve sought out emotional comfort from others but nothing physical

What a lovely way to describe cheating on someone and then marrying them

misteraustria27

Guys like this still exist? And there are women who accept that?
You don’t have a “I don’t want another child” problem. You have a giant marriage problem.
DirtyLil_Thing

If he already refuses to help with one child, what makes him think he deserves another? He wants the title of “dad” without the responsibilities. NTA.
NUredditNU

NTA. If he’s too poor for you not to work, he can’t afford the traditions he’s used to. Leave his sorry, broke ass. You’re already a single mother.
Unusual-Dish4896

You already have 2 children, a 3 and a 37, and a job. That is enough for anyone to handle. Do not add another kid to the pile.
RJack151

NTA. He is being a terrible partner. Have him replace the light switches in the rooms with motion detector switches.
BlueGreen_1956

Question: What kind of job does he have and what kind of job do you have?
res06myi

Why the ever loving fuck are you still married to him?!
throwbackblue

NTA, all you said was he needed help, not a big deal.
Remarkable-Arm4921

You already have 2 children. Need I say more
TheSnarkyObserver

Why are you still with this person?

Conclusion

The original poster (OP) is feeling deep resentment stemming from an unequal division of household labor and childcare responsibilities, compounded by her husband’s refusal to assist despite her chronic health issues and ADHD. The central conflict lies in the OP’s need for partnership and support versus the husband’s adherence to traditional gender roles and his use of minor infractions, like leaving lights on, as justification for withholding meaningful help.

Is the OP justified in expressing her desire to halt plans for a second child due to her husband’s lack of support, or did this statement constitute an unfair reaction to his frustration over small household tasks? The core question remains whether the disparity in effort justifies halting major life decisions like expanding the family.

Categories Uncategorized