AITA for rejecting a girl as revenge?

He once asked Clara out, only to be met with rejection that pierced deep, igniting a fire within him to transform his life. That painful memory lingered, a cruel reminder of what he thought was petty but ultimately became the catalyst for change.

Now, fate thrust them back together, sparking a connection that blossomed into dates and shared moments. Yet beneath the surface, a shadow of unforgiveness gnawed at him, threatening to unravel the fragile hope they had begun to build.

AITA for rejecting a girl as revenge?

So, to start off, maybe, it was a bit petty of me tbh. Anyway, I asked this girl Clara out on a date about a year ago. I was a completely different person then, and she turned me down.

It stung like hell, but it did encourage me to better myself. Since then I’ve gotten in better shape, became more confident and generally I’ve had more luck with girls. I still never forgot what made me improve though, and that will always be a shitty memory.

Anyway, me and a few friends I’ve made since last year went out to a gathering. I’m still fairly new in their circle, and surprise! Clara was there. I think she recognized me but I wasn’t sure.

Me and her hit it off, and at the end of the night we had a date planned. The date went pretty well and we went on our second one last friday.

After this I went home and thought about where to go next, and I realized I couldn’t really forgive her. So, she hit me up asking if we were going out again, and I sort of make a joke of it, blew it off and put her on mute.

I haven’t responded since then, and our mutual friends say she’s been pretty upset, since she gets attached to people quickly, but the revenge I got was so sweet!

But, maybe I was an asshole though, what does Reddit think?

Here’s how people reacted:

MarcusKilgannon

YTA

Unless Clara somehow brutally rejected you, I don’t see why turning down a date offer over a year ago is doing you wrong. It doesn’t sound from your description of her that she would have been mean about it.

People change. You changed yourself for the better, possibly to have better luck with girls like Clara.

Your change worked! Until you act like a total dick head to wanting to reject this girl solely because she didn’t go on a date with you before your change. If you couldn’t forgive her (which shouldn’t be even an issue here), don’t go on dates with her just to reject her after.

She turned you down a year ago because she just wasn’t interested. You’re turning her down because you’re a petty asshole.

sasha_bo

YTA.

If this was something you truly couldn’t get over then you should have never gone on a date with her in the first place. You’re being a bit of a dick by ghosting her as well rather then being upfront.

You have no idea why she declined you a year ago. You are butthurt about it and have decided to be petty in response. She had no obligation to date you back then just because you asked. “the revenge I got was so sweet” – YTA just for that comment alone.

boringparentoftwo

YTA –
1. you have no idea why she turned you down a year ago
2. You admit that you weren’t the same person then and you’re better now – would you now have gone out with you then?
3. You like her, you had a nice date, and now you’re blowing her off? Yes, you’re the asshole. You’re also hurting yourself.
4. Petty is never a good trait. Stop that. You’re better than that.
Mac4491

YTA

She wasn’t attracted to you then. You’ve changed. She is attracted to you now, or has learned to see beyond looks and is attracted to you as a person.

Nobody is obliged to go out with someone just because they have a good personality. Looks matter and first impressions are often made with looks.

Whythebigpaws

YTA. A girl turning you down is not revenge-worthy. It’s entitled of you to think she wasnt allowed to say no to you without repurcussions. By all means, turn her down now if you aren’t attracted to her, but do it properly, don’t ghost her and don’t act as if rejecting her is some major win for you.
Vigilant1e

YTA.

Revenge for what? Do you think she had some obligation to go on a date with you just because you asked?

Not only that, but you organised a date, then flaked and ghosted her?

Damn man. That isn’t just an asshole, that’s like a ‘post very hot curry’ level of being a raging asshole.

the-howl

YTA, there was no revenge to be had here. She has the right to turn you down, she has the right to change her opinion of you.

You’ve just proved that you’re an asshole and that she got a lucky escape. Can’t imagine what the poor girl would’ve gone through having you as a boyfriend.

AeternusDoleo

YTA – but only for the way you did it. Had you just straightup told her “I can’t get over you blowing me off a year like ago, nothing has changed so we’re not going to work out” it’d have been fine. But doing it in a rude mute until she hangs up way? There are limits.
russharv9

YTA. You really haven’t bettered yourself as well as you think you have.

[Also, you creeped me the fuck out with your actions and for one reason.](https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/a317t3/til_serial_killer_ted_bundy_dated_a_girl_who/)

Bletcherino

A million times YTA

Dude, who gives a shit if she rejected you? That happens, quit being an incel and move on with your life. Just because she wasn’t attracted to you before doesn’t mean she deserves to hurt. Grow the hell up

Fluffymunchkin

YTA, was your initial rejection in any way related to your childish attitude? People get rejected my friend, don’t take it so hard (I know how hard that is) because you ended up growing as a person to some extent.
t4h4r4o4w4a4w4a4y4

YTA x100

Reason 32, 586 why women feel uncomfortable saying no to men. Holy shit. This girl said no to a date a YEAR AGO and you’re still crying about it and trying to get her back? Just wow. How fucking petty.

teebax929

YTA. You asked her out, and she said no, for what could be any number of reasons. That was her right. Now you’re playing games with her heart. That’s not cool at all, and it sounds like you don’t deserve her.
ok_m80

INFO: what did she actually do to you that made you feel so hurt? You are too vague about that. Turning someone down for a date doesn’t deserve this kind of revenge.
ProbablyMyJugs

Yeah, YTA. this is ridiculously petty and immature. If you’re going to play games like this you should put a pause on dating for awhile.
YeetTheRich

YTA – but Clara is lucky you showed your asshole cards this early. Punishing people for saying no is not an excellent trait.
ms_bong

YTA, not because of the reason you dont want to go out with her, but for the way you did it. Just tell her the reason!
Feroc

YTA

She just turned you down, unless she made fun of you back then I don’t see any reason for what you did.

Conclusion

The original poster experienced significant pain after an initial rejection, which motivated personal change. Now, having successfully reconnected with the person who rejected them and subsequently ended contact following a second date, the central conflict lies between the satisfaction of perceived revenge and the ethical implications of deliberately hurting someone they were beginning a relationship with.

Was the original poster’s decision to seek emotional payback by cutting off contact after achieving what they wanted, justified by their past hurt, or did this action demonstrate a failure to move past the initial rejection in a mature manner?

Categories Uncategorized