AITA for getting alimony ended when my ex moved in with her boyfriend?

The user, a 41-year-old man (OP), shares a 12-year-old son with his ex-wife (37F), following a divorce five years prior. The ex-wife currently lives in their former three-bedroom home, where she also houses her 10-year-old nephew (her sister’s son).

Recently, the ex-wife began a relationship, became pregnant, and moved her new boyfriend (who has a daughter) into the home. This arrangement resulted in the OP’s son and his cousin sharing a room, which prompted the son to request living with the OP full-time. The OP then initiated legal proceedings to seek full custody, which he had previously considered but not pursued.

AITA for getting alimony ended when my ex moved in with her boyfriend?

Hello, I (41M) have a twelve year old son with an ex (37F) with my ex wife. We divorced 5 years ago. I pay child support and (formerly) alimony. Shortly after our divorce, she took in her sister’s son, who is currently ten.

They live in our old home, which has three bedrooms.

Almost 2 years ago, my ex started dating a guy and is now 4ish months pregnant. He moved in about the same time she found out she was pregnant. He has a daughter from a previous relationship.

His daughter was given her own room and my son and his cousin now share a room.

My son is upset about this and asked to live with me full time. I went to my lawyer and began that process to get full custody. I have wanted full custody since we divorced, but my son had never indicated he wanted that so I did not push for it.

I also found out from my lawyer that my ex living with her boyfriend gives me the right to terminate alimony in our state (my previous lawyer said it was only if she got remarried).

So, I told him to go for it.

The court has ended the alimony. The custody is taking longer and won’t be decided until after the holidays. My ex is pissed about the loss of alimony it because she is only working part time and her boyfriend is a medically retired fireman.

So, they are struggling financially. But, I feel that is extra money I could put away for my kid down the line.

AITA?

Here’s how people reacted:

Background_Fox6436

NTA, you don’t owe her a living anymore, and your son wants to live with you. Just because her boyfriend is medically retired as a fireman, does not mean he can’t work at all, nor her either. She is pregnant, not dying. She may have to work opposite shifts from said boyfriend until her baby arrives so that an adult is present in the home always, but if your son is going to live with you, then that is all on her. Sounds like she wants only partial responsibility for being an adult. Your son should have interviews coming up to see which parent is more suited for him to live with, in many states this is how it is decided. Should be interviews for both you and his mother too, but then again, your state may not handle custody in this way. Is she fighting to retain custody? You didn’t say above.
chez2202

NTA.

This woman got your marital home, alimony and child support. Then she took in her nephew. Then she took in her boyfriend and his child and made YOUR SON, the only child you should have been paying for, share a bedroom.

On what planet is it reasonable for her to expect you to pay for her, her nephew, her boyfriend, his child and their upcoming baby?

She has had a good run. You have paid for her and her nephew for 5 years. You paid for her boyfriend and his kid for 4 months that you know of.

Being medically retired from the fire service means that he has a good pension. It also means that he can’t work for the fire service anymore, it doesn’t mean that he can’t work elsewhere.

Strange_Jackfruit_89

NTA.

In my opinion alimony is a transitional type of payment to adjust to being single and the loss of a former spouses support and income. Obviously she’s adjusted to it by finding another partner and getting pregnant by them.

While it is the best move to allow the girl to have a bedroom of her own, it is not fair to do so at the expense of her own child and further disrupt his life by bringing in an additional child (the nephew) and getting pregnant. Your son should not have to grin and bear all these changes and I don’t blame him for wanting out.

DisneyBuckeye

NTA

There is a big difference between child support and alimony (spousal support). The alimony is to help keep your spouse in the lifestyle they were used to, but is typically not forever. Now that she’s with a new guy, it shouldn’t be your responsibility to pay for her lifestyle any longer. It’s not your problem that he doesn’t/can’t work.

Best wishes for success in the custody changes!

Plane_Jane_Is_God

Alimony is at the discretion of the court. Of course when someone is paying alimony they are going to argue to the court to reduce their payments, that’s just a no brainer. So your wife shouldn’t be mad at you for doing what any reasonable person would have expected you to, she should be mad at the judge for using their discretion to grant your request.
jeffprop

NTA. Your ex should have been aware of the consequences before letting her BF move in.
You should ask your lawyer if you are entitled to back pay for the alimony you paid that you should not have after the BF moved in. If so, tell your ex that if she fights the loss of alimony, you will push for getting paid back the money you should not have paid.
fsmontario

NTA your son is likely old enough to talk to the judge himself. More than likely his mother will try to tell him what to say, you tell him to say what is the truth and what he wants. Let him know the judge will likely ask him why he wants to live with you and that it is his right to say how he feels and what he wants. Don’t feed him what to say.
Bluemicha

Alimony is absolutely not your problem. She has had plenty of time to get a job and she was able to chose a partner who has financial problems. How in any way is that your fault?? She is the AH for even expecting you to continue paying for her life without you in it. Hopefully you can get full custody of your son as well.
No_Glove_1575

NTA. She is in a 2 parent household now. Time to put her easy money to an end (especially when you get custody). You are NOT responsible for financing her BFs kids and them shacking up. Or your former nephew. Let her and her man pay their own bills – your son being taken care of is your only concern.
writing_mm_romance

So ex and her bf thought they were going to be able to live high on the cash cow off your child support and alimony payments? Funny that two people who can’t support themselves, have decided to have another child, I’m sure that’s going to make things easier.
PhDTARDIS

NTA. It’s extremely rare for alimony to last forever and she shouldn’t really ‘double dip’ by getting payments from you while he’s contributing to the household. Probably was avoiding remarriage so that she could keep riding the gravy train.
Lann42016

I doubt you’ll get full custody just because your kid has to share a room. You’re probably looking at 50/50 split and if you make close to the same amount there will be no child support. NTA though for not paying what you don’t have to.
RockerStubbs

Sounds like your alimony was paying for a whole house full of people! Get custody of your son if you both want it. Then you don’t have to pay child support either, highly likely that money is NOT going to just your son. NTA
ProfessionalKey7356

Not your problem anymore. Courts cleared you and once you have custody, child support can end too. She should be grateful if she doesn’t have to pay you child support when you win.
waylorn

NTA, you probably should have done the custody fight first though, then end the alimony cause now she’ll fight you on custody harder to stop herself from losing that money too.
LosAngel1935

NTA if your son wants to live with you, he should be allowed too. He’s twelve not a baby and should be able to choose.

Your ex’s financial problems are not your problem.

YuansMoon

NTA: in this day and age, alimony shouldn’t even exist. Woman are fully able to have careers during marriage if they choose, or resume careers after taking a break.
Mother_Search3350

NTAH

It is not your responsibility to support your ex and her sisters kid and her unemployed boyfriend and his kids

You are ONLY responsible for your son. 

Humble_Pen_7216

NTA. She is no longer your spouse and doesn’t get a portion of your income for the rest of your lives. She can get a full time job if money is tight.
throwitaway3857

NTA. She can work full time. They abused you for far too long with alimony.

They shouldn’t have gotten pregnant if they’re struggling financially.

lovebeinganasshole

So you’re supposed to support an entire family not related to you? No NTA.

She’s an asshole for even thinking about being mad.

Flatulent_Opposum

NTA. You’re protecting your kid and yourself. Your ex can piss off if she thinks she’s entitled to you supporting her lifestyle.
Away-Understanding34

NTA….she moved on with another man so she shouldn’t be expecting you to support them. Your only obligation is to your kid now.
BlueGreen_1956

NTA

Alimony should not be a thing anyway.

If you are able to get full custody, SHE should be paying child support to YOU.

KrofftSurvivor

You are responsible for your son, not your ex, nor her other dependents.
You’re doing the right thing.
Screwsrloose1969

NTA… guess she needs a full time job. I hope you get your son and she has to pay child support to you.
campsguy

Are you an asshole for not giving free money to people who have ZERO right over it? Like what?
Independent-Floor485

Not at all. Take care of your child. You are not responsible for her lifestyle
Braga3041

She can get a full time job. Now it is her new boyfriend to take care of her.
angry-always80

Nta she has a partner and you are no longer financially responsible for her.
ClintEastwoodsNext

NTA.

I hope your son ends up in the best possible living situation.

DesperateLobster69

NTA no way you should be supporting your ex *AND her new family*!!!
BAHGate

NTA and absolutely file for child support once you have custody.
Responsible_Blood789

He should apply for child support if his son moves in with him
Pre3Chorded

Why are they having more children if they can’t afford them?
BrodyP-LV

Alimony is bullshit 80% of the time anyways. Fuck her
Quiet_Village_1425

I hope you got child support terminated as well.
meoptional

So you are just doing this to piss her off?

Conclusion

The Original Poster (OP) is facing a conflict where his desire to secure full custody for his son, driven by the son’s unhappiness with the living situation, clashes with the financial distress experienced by his ex-wife following the termination of alimony payments.

The core question is whether the OP was justified in seeking full custody and terminating alimony based on the change in his ex-wife’s living situation, or if his actions were unfair given the resulting financial hardship on his ex-partner and her new family unit?

Categories Uncategorized