The weight of his silence pressed down on her as she sought answers, only to be met with defensiveness and confusion. His world was complicated, tangled with fractured relationships and newborn cries, a reality she had never been prepared to face. In that moment, her heart raced with shock and uncertainty, caught between empathy and the sudden, overwhelming truth.

I (25F) have been dating a guy (31M) for the past 2 months. However, last night he told me he has 2 kids.
I was honestly shockeddd that this was the first time he was telling me. Especially since we’ve been dating over Christmas and didn’t even mention it? I’ve never dated anyone who had kids before, so naturally I was curious and started asking questions.
Whenever I got to my 4th question he started getting slightly defensive, asking if I was I the cops, because I was asking so many question. Lmaooo.
Eventually I was able to get through to him and explain how I was feeling, since he basically kept this a secret and sprung it on me as if it was nothing. He opened up and said that his kids have two different mothers and that they don’t get along because they kids were born only 4 months apart.
Andd the youngest is only 9 months old.
At this point I’m literally flabbergasted.
We were both kinda drunk and I to him I would go back to my own apartment because I needed to think about it all. He didn’t want me to leave on my own and take the subway (we live in nyc) so we both went back to his place to sleep and I slept in the spare room.
I left ealryyy around 5am and now he’s blowing up my phone asking me what’s wrong and what happened, that this was the reason he didn’t want to tell me he had kids because I wouldn’t like him anymore.
Pleaseeee someone tell me I’m not loosing my mind and that this man is crazy? I’m actually laughing so much writing this because how tf did I not notice this man has two kids? Is he that good of a liar?
At this point I’m ready to break up with him, because who even is this man? If he lied about that, what else is he lying about?
Am I being an asshole about this situation?
Conclusion
The original poster is experiencing shock and a profound sense of betrayal after discovering her new partner has two children whom he deliberately concealed for two months, creating a significant conflict between her expectation of honesty in a new relationship and his choice to withhold critical life information.
Given the magnitude of this undisclosed fact, the central question remains: Is the man’s decision to hide his parental status due to fear of rejection, or is this behavior evidence of a fundamental trustworthiness issue that warrants immediate termination of the relationship?
Here’s how people reacted:
Two, keeping the fact he has one kid from you is bad enough, but he has two from different women and it sounds like there’s some drama there that I’m sure you don’t wanna get caught up in.
Three, if I were you I’d do the same thing. Actually, I was in a similar situation a few years ago. I was gonna go out with this guy who said he was married before but had no kids. I found out on Facebook he had a son and he told me he didn’t tell me because it was a dealbreaker for some women.
And just some advice as I have been through a similar situation, if/when you break up with him he may try to manipulate you and say things like you’re selfish or hate kids or are judgmental. Do not believe that for one second! And I’m saying this as someone who is a teacher and made the choice to work with kids. Dating someone with kids is not for everyone because the ex(es) are going to be around and the kids will most likely come first.
If you need to, tell him you no longer wish to date him because he lied to you about something huge. Which would be a fair reason to break up. Or you can say whatever you want but please please please leave him! It’s only been two months and this sounds like a disaster waiting to happen. Start the new year fresh!
Best of luck!
If he’s hidden the fact that he’s fathered 2 children in the past year I wouldn’t be surprised if there are others he’s hiding.
If he can lie about this what else is he lying about? Get out while you can and before you end up tied to him the way these other women are. Let’s be honest it’s not about the fact that he has kids, it’s that he lied about their existence.
He lied because he knew there was a chance you wouldn’t be interested if you knew he had kids as baggage.
Dump him immediately. He lied. He manipulated you. Stole your time, used you for sex and pleasure for himself, while diminishing and creating a false relationship with you that sneaky hid parts of himself he KNEW would be conditional to consent of your time and body.
He violated you. Big time. No, it’s not technically rape, but it’s still a violation to not give you all the relevant information he knew would be conditional to moving forward both sexually and romantically.
The only thing is, that’s still manipulation – albeit probably out of cowardice than anything else. He might not be a terrible man, but he’s been really stupid. Hopefully he’ll learn from this.
Not sure why he was surprised/defensive that you asked questions, surely he should have been more upset if you cared so little for his children that you brushed past it.
Red flags all over the place.
Actual thought process: I’m leaving because you hid it from me and just sprung it on me. What else are you hiding?
I understand you might not want to say anything on the first date, but this kind of stuff needs to be out in the open quickly. If not it makes you look shady.
Anyone else read it as the kids didn’t get along with each other at first. I thought those babies had beef with each other.
I think this guy needs to be on his own for a while and concentrate on being a dad.
He lied, on purpose, to up his chances. If a person specifically omits information to gain a benefit, they’re manipulating the situation.
He proved that he’s willing to lie to get his way. You can’t trust someone like that. And then he tried to make you out to be overreacting to him lying.
If he hid his kids .. imagine what else he is hiding … go do a search and see what his criminal history is
The kids are 4 months apart – 2 moms = he’s a cheater … that’s why he didn’t tell you
That’s not a small lie. It’s an absolute tirade of lies. Massive lies. Find someone else who doesn’t lie like he does, or date till you get another good match, or, be single 🙂
Good luck.
Two baby momma’s and the kids are only four months apart. Do you honestly think he’s ever gonna be loyal to you with that history?
What kind of father pretends he doesn’t have children
Unless of course you want to be baby momma no 3.
Its not like he hid it by accident. He knows what he did.