AITAH for not wanting to put my (25f) life on hold for my boyfriend’s (30m) dog?

In the quiet moments between love and life’s expectations, a young woman finds herself caught in the gentle tug of two hearts beating to different rhythms. Though her partner’s kindness and warmth wrap around her like a comforting blanket, the unspoken divide grows—anchored by dreams of family, roots, and the places they each call home.

Amid the shared laughter and their cherished pets, an undercurrent of uncertainty flows. She yearns to explore the world on her own terms, while he clings to the familiar embrace of his parents’ neighborhood. Their love is real, but the paths they envision stretch in opposite directions, whispering a poignant question about what it means to grow together and apart.

AITAH for not wanting to put my (25f) life on hold for my boyfriend's (30m) dog?

I have been with my partner for about two years and he treats me great. He’s a very loving and kind person and we get along great. One problem we have had since the start of our relationship that I thought I could ignore is that we are in different places in life, I feel like.

We are 25 (me) and 30 (him). He has lived in big cities and done a lot of different jobs related to his field. He is still not fully ready to settle down and have kids and stuff but he does want to live close to his parents.

I do not want this. I feel like I have very little experience in what I actually want to do and have not gotten the chance to live in places I want to live in. I am not close with my parents and honestly have a pretty poor relationship with them so I do not relate to his desire.

I understand why he wants to but I just never had a family like that.

We have two pets. I have a little cat. He has a senior dog. I do love his dog. She’s great. She’s super sweet and chill and I take care of her a lot. She’s a big dog though so travel is somewhat hard for her.

I exposed my cat to the car and carrier trained her. She’s great on long road trips and planes.

I applied to my dream job awhile ago and my partner was supportive. I did have a concern that it was across the country and far from his parents and he said we’d figure it out when we got there.

Well, I got the job and now we are trying to figure it out and it sucks.

My boyfriend keeps asking if there’s a branch closer to his hometown and I keep telling him no, it does not work like that. It is also kind of my dream city to live in so I do want to be in that specific location.

He keeps trying to talk me out of it and I told him to tell me the exact problems he has with me taking this job.

He told me: “I want to be within reasonable driving distance from my parents. My dog is part of their family and it’s important to me that they see each other. She’s like their granddaughter.”

This kind of aggravated me. I suggested they can fly to see us and he just shut me down. His parents are retired and wealthy. They go on a lot of vacations a year but he said he didn’t want them to go through the hassle.

He said his dog MUST be in their house otherwise it’s not the same. It really pissed me off.

Today I told him “I will not be putting my life on hold for your dog, if that is actually the only reason you don’t want me to move. I am going with or without you.” and I left. He has been blowing up my phone apologizing and saying we can work things out but I really do not think we can.

Here’s how people reacted:

PunIntended1234

Girl, I wish I could come to your house, gather up all of your things, take you to the new city and put you in a nice place and then go back to my home! Please, for the love of your future, do not change your mind! You did the right thing. Your boyfriend is settled and he wants to live a particular type of life. You do not. You’re too young to shackle yourself to someone who is so set in his ways. Say you turn down the job and then the dog dies in a year. Then what? He will find some other excuse. Live your life first and then decide what you need and want. Right now, you just don’t know. You may get to the new city and hate it. You might love it. You might love the job. You may hate the job. You need to figure things out. You’re too young to have regrets about things. Also, you aren’t sure about him. I could tell in your wording. Stick to your heart and follow your dreams! You’re destined for more, but you have to go out and get it! I wish you the best!
Ereisor

You’re Sort Of The AH. First, don’t give up on your dreams or put them on hold for anyone. Where the “Sort of” comes in is with his dog and parents. It’s not in any way, shape, or form a bad thing that his dog and parents are a priority for him. They’ve been a part of his life for WAY longer than you have. You don’t get to try to change that. If you both aren’t able to come up with a compromise, then you should both have an amicable discussion about going your separate ways. Because if you stay, you’ll resent him. If you guilt him into going with you, he will resent you. And you guys will split up anyways.
Also, dogs are better than people. Not everyone feels the same way, but my dog gets my full attention because she gives me hers. She’s my kid. And I have yet to meet a human being that is better than a dog. People are self-serving, deceitful, and all around just not fun to be around.
Awesomekidsmom

Hun his wants are not your wants.
He is trying to quash your dream job with this reason – but this sums it up – he would rather you pass on your dream than his parents who travel often take a plane to visit their granddog because that trip is a hassle where their other trips aren’t?
This proves he just doesn’t want to go & he expects/wants you to give up your dreams for him. He is literally putting his dogs relationship with his parents above your happiness- like WTF?
Go, be happy & enjoy your new life in a city you want. Explore the world when you can
You absolutely must take your job. If you don’t you will resent him & spend your life playing what if.
rasmorak

I don’t think this is an “automatic break-up” situation and I’m fucking sick of seeing posts like this where everyone immediately says “Break up, it’s irreconcilable.”

Don’t fall into the trap of “we can’t work this out”. Either he moves with you or he doesn’t. Especially because it sounds like wants to try to work it out. I also doubt it’s really about the dog. Dude is probably worried about moving to the other side of the country. I would be too, and I’m extremely well traveled. Sit down and talk to him about this.

Don’t listen to the shitters in the comments that scream “break up” every time there’s a difficult situation in a relationship.

GAB104

NTA

Maybe he’s throwing away a good woman for — a dog? His parents’ relationship with his dog? His parents not traveling? I don’t really understand his reasoning.

Also, he said before you applied for the job that y’all would figure it out. Then he blocked any chance that he goes with you. Then you said okay bye, and now he’s saying the same thing.

But I don’t think he’s willing to move for you, so maybe y’all love each other, but aren’t compatible because you want different things.

I think you did the right thing to leave, and I don’t think you should go back.

reddvad

Btw, OP none of what your bf is saying is a compromise on his part. He wants to have all the things that he needs, with no room for compromise or negotiation.
This is a big red flag because none of this is “figuring it out together”.
He knew where the job was, since you had expressed this concern beforehand, and I guess he thought it wouldn’t be a big deal even if you got it cause clearly he wasn’t prepared.
Leave him because this not someone who will be happy for you getting the things you want if they don’t align with what he wants.
Global_Paper_7351

Nobody is the AH. You two are at different stages of your life and want different things from life and imagine yourself in different situations in the future. I know I’m a stranger and I don’t know how much you love each other but if you can’t meet halfway then break up. Cherish that affection in your hearts and move on individually. Otherwise resentment will grow and this topic of “I have given up so much for you” will be present in every argument you will have. I wish you the best
lexisloced

I can see why you’re not good with your family lmao. Yeah cut them all out. If he genuinely wants to work on it , he should’ve voiced his concerns before you accepted the job. A they are WEALTHY, why can’t his parents just fly down and see the dog for christs sake. It is a dog, they will get over it. This is your dream, do not let a man who can’t even communicate with you take that away from you. If he wants you , then he will do what it takes .
ChiefChunkEm_

Depends on what the dream job is exactly and the quality of the boyfriend and the relationship. Long term, who you select as your life partner is EXPONENTIALLY more important than most dream jobs. In fact, it’s arguably the most impactful decision you can make in your entire life. If he’s that good he’s worth far more than the job but if not and the job is life changing then take the job.
Yoongi_SB_Shop

NTA

There’s nothing wrong with prioritizing your career, especially at your age. There’s nothing wrong with him wanting to live close to his parents either. But it is wrong for him to try to pressure you to give up your dream job for his comfort. Your priorities are incompatible. I would take the job and break up with him. You will meet someone else in your new city.

Nettsie

This whole story gives me mommas boy vibes
Mommas boys don’t make good husband’s.
In a relationship the “battleground” is stacked one to one… some times you win… some times you don’t
When you’re with a mommas boy the battles are stacked you against 2… always ….
My advice is take the job… kiss the dog good bye…. and don’t look back
Ok-Cardiologist-3612

He told you what he wanted, you knew right away you didn’t want the same. You applied to your dream job and already knew somewhere in your mind that meant leaving the relationship behind.

It’s okay to split if you don’t have the same desires or are not in the same stage of life. Break up as amicably as possible so you both can move on.

ophaus

He’s not ready to move away from his parents, not ready to have kids, not willing to do… Anything? It seems like you two have very different priorities, and his seem kind of childish. This seems like a very important opportunity and experience for you… I’d say go for it. He can go with you or stay where he is without you.
Simulis1

Tale the job work on you. However I don’t blame him w a senior dog. Theu become your fa.ily like a child. We live our dogs so very much. This must be hard on you both for sure. Take the job and also be supportive of him. Thats a good man there. Put relationship on hold for a bit perhaps. Distance relationship for a while.
Pokesquidpoke

Take the job. You sound like a woman who has goals and a direction of where you want your life going. Sure like anyone you can give up on your goals for love. But if you truly couldn’t see yourself spending your life without this person you wouldn’t be here on reddit looking for justification.
Sad_Construction_668

He’s telling you that he wants you to be part of his life, but he’s not willing to sacrifice to be part of yours.

This is absolutely the time in your life to take the job and clarify for both of you if you want each other, or if you want something else more.

Intelligent-Status29

You’d be throwing away your career and life for a man. That’s what your family should’ve said. Pfft. You’re NTA at all. You have authority & autonomy over your life. Do what you want for yourself, the dog is more important to him than your relationships.
Jerseygirl2468

NTA but you realize you both want very different things, right? You could try long distance, or just put the relationship on hold for a while, but to me you need to follow your dream, and if he doesn’t want to come along, that’s his choice.
mf_dcap

I am rooting for the guy and his dog. Sorry. From what you wrote I have a feeling there’s more going on than just the dog. Gl anyways. And as a closer: regretting something you didn’t do is worse than regretting something you did do. Gl!
HotAndShrimpy

Definitely take the job and move without him.
This “reason” is crazy and a weird excuse when really he just doesn’t want to and doesn’t care what it means for your life. You gotta go girl, never give up your dreams for a man at 25.
buffinator2

I would have wished you well and cut you loose already. Not sure what he’s waiting on. Make the decision for him. You’re young, it’s a dream job, and you know he’s not ready to settle down. Move and have fun in the city.
Glittering-List-465

Keep the job. It’s insane people think you should ditch it for a guy who has mommy issues, which is what it boils down to. He can’t live his own life without being close to his parents. That’s just weird. Nta.
WritPositWrit

NTA. Never put your life dreams on hold for someone you’re dating. Take the job. Move for the job. Either he moves with you or you go LDR or you break up. That can all be decided later.
JunePlum79

NTA. You will regret it and resent him if you stay. He’s too attached to the parents/dog in an unhealthy way…geez, he needs to realize his SO will not want that unhealthy attachment.
whitrva

NTA. This man is telling you there will always be something else he prioritizes above you. Don’t waste your dreams on him. Take the job, make the move & live your best life!
punsexual-meme

Take the job. It’s not about whether you’re the asshole or he is; it’s as you said, you’re in different places in life. That happens.
Pale_Drawing_6004

Sounds like you want different things and it may be best to go your own ways and reconnect once you’re ready if you want to.
Dillydrop

Take the job. This is going to get rocky. If you stay you will resent your partner. If he goes with you he will resent you.
PercentageKooky7064

Take the job, and move. If you don’t you’ll resent him and be angry about it.

Stick to what you told him.

Good luck

Hot_Time_8628

>My dog is part of their family and it’s important to me that they see each other.

Move on. This is a sad line of bs.

ColdSeason2019

TAKE THE JOB!!! Don’t live with regrets! You’re at different stages of life- that’s a legit reason to end things
childrenofthewind

NTA. This man does not want to compromise or settle down. Please take the job and move. You won’t regret it.
ActStunning3285

Your lives are branching. It’s normal. Go your separate ways. You’ll both find what you need and love later.
Odd_Personality85

Take the job and go. Don’t give him a hard time, it’s his choice and he’s being open and honest with you.
donjuanamigo

Brand new account. No replies by OP and posted the same story twice. Karma farming.
Beneficial-Pride890

I think it’s not about the dog at all. He’s really trying to sell it though.
Bartok_The_Batty

NAH You two are in different stages and aren’t compatible.

Conclusion

The original poster (OP) is facing a major conflict between pursuing a deeply desired career opportunity in a specific location and the resistance from her long-term partner, who bases his objection primarily on the logistics of his senior dog visiting his parents.

Given that the partner has now apologized and stated they can work things out, the core question remains: Should the OP compromise her significant life and career goals based on her partner’s stated inflexible requirement concerning his pet’s proximity to his family, or is the career move a non-negotiable priority for her personal future?

Categories Uncategorized