I Let A Girl Try To Stick Me With A $300 Tab And Now She’s Reporting Me To My Mom

In a bustling Toronto bar, a young man’s spontaneous charm collided with an unexpected twist of fate. What began as a confident move to impress a captivating stranger spiraled into an unforgettable lesson in humility and consequences, as the cost of a night’s bravado came crashing down with the weight of family ties.

Caught between pride and responsibility, he faced the fallout of a reckless decision, exposed by a surprising connection that bridged strangers and kin. This is a story of youthful impulsiveness clashing with the harsh realities of respect, money, and the unexpected ways our actions echo beyond the moment.

I Let A Girl Try To Stick Me With A $300 Tab And Now She's Reporting Me To My Mom

I’m m23 and few months ago I was at a nice bar in Toronto with my boys and I saw this really hot girl. Decided to shoot my shot and we spoke and danced for a bit and I offered to buy her a drink and she gladly accompanied me to the bar, when I got there I was like can I have a beer and whatever she wants.

She promptly says can I get 4 double shots of 1942. Thats like $75 a shot for a double of 1942 and I was like wtf and she said there for her friends and patted me on the back. When the bartender came back I slapped a $10 bill on the table and told him she’d be covering the shots and walked away.

She was pissed and yelling the normal insults lol.

Well it turns out my mom works with her and they were talking and my mom showed her a picture of me (god damn it mom!) and she instantly recognized me and remembered my name and told my mom about what I did.

My mom then called me and said I’m a huge asshole and told me to send her the cost of the 4 drinks which was like $325 with tips.

I just laughed and told my mom I’m not doing that and my mom said that the girl thinks I’m a huge asshole and douche and she agrees LOL.

Here’s how people reacted:

Scoobi_Snaxx

ESH? I think your offer to buy her a drink should stand and you should reimburse her for the one shot and appropriate tip amount. But, as for the other shots for her friends? That’s on her, and she is a bit of an AH for assuming that would cover their cost. You probably could have handled it better when she ordered the shots which makes you a bit of an AH too, plus your mom would appreciate you doing something.
ManOnTheM00n69

ESH This is honestly the hardest ESH ever. There is no way you should’ve paid for her friends drinks. And your mom had no right to call you an ass, because you mostly weren’t. That being said, you should’ve paid for HER drink. So no, I don’t really think you’re an asshole, but the things I can say are limited. So you made a tiny mistake while the girl and your mom are the real assholes.
badb-crow

NTA. I thought this was going to be a case of “offered to buy a girl a drink but she didn’t want to sleep with me so I left her the tab” but nope, this threw me a curveball. It was douchy of her to try and get you to pay for expensive drinks for all her friends when that isn’t what you offered. I can’t understand why your mom would take her side.
amyliz436

I was all ready to say you were TA till reading the part where you offered her a drink and she ordered FOUR! WHAT THE HELL.

NTA, she tried some bull move that you rebuffed. She knew she was taking the mick when she patted you. I’m impressed with your nerve to straight up reject that and walk away.

Side note hilarious that it still bugs her!

QTeaDragon

NTA

If someone offered to buy me a drink I wouldn’t ask for a round for my friends… that just takes the piss. $325 seems like a crap ton of money. Although I’m not sure of the exchange rate between Toronto and the UK…
I think there is chivalry and courtesy, but that has a limit when another person wants to take the piss.

[deleted]

NTA

She was totally trying to take advantage of a nice gesture. You’d be an asshole if she ordered a simple drink just for her, but you are by no means required to spend over 300 dollars for her friends too. If anything she is the asshole expecting you to by drinks for her whole group.

ApartLocksmith1

NTA – I am proud of you for not letting that girl take advantage of you. Her behaviour was rude and totally unacceptable.

Your mom needs to get a sense of perspective here too, she should be chastising the girl for trying to manipulate her son. Again, no way are you the A/h.

throwawaytimes101

NTA. You said you would buy her a drink and she thought she could $325 worth of shots for her friends? C’mon. You could have handled it more smoothly but you’re not an asshole per se. If your mom feels so strongly she can give her the money and say it’s from you.
tickeymouse

NTA. I can’t believe she had the audacity to order not one $75 drink, but 4. If I were her, I wouldn’t be able to tell someone this story without wishing to dissapear from embarassment.
readingismyzen

NTA. Absolutely not.

Bonkers and supremely rude of the woman to take advantage like that, and what crazy drink is your mum on to tell you to send the cost of the drinks over?

rolz63

This is pure gold I can’t believe she ratted on you to your mother.

NTA tell her she can have her friends split the bill since they all wanted a shot too lmao.

DOMINATOR-AMER

ESH. She shouldn’t have ordered stupid expensive drinks, not cool. But you should have been upfront with her about not paying for them. Communication, people.
Doctor-Amazing

NTA obviously

Also I’m amazed that a shot of anything costs $75. Goldschläger doesn’t even cost that much and it literally has gold in it.

mossimoto11

NTA. She tried to take advantage of you offering HER a drink and then orders 4 expensive shots for her and her friends?!? That’s rude af
arewereadyforthis

NTA. Though you should have stopped the barkeep before he had time to pour the drinks. Would have saved him a lot of trouble probably.
KeremsWorld

NTA, she took advantage of you being interested in her and it’s very rude for her to snitch on you to your mother like a 7 year old.
MildredNatwick

ESH. What she did was pretty awful, but you could’ve overruled the order on the spot and not left her to pay it.

Conclusion

The original poster (OP) experienced a situation where he intentionally avoided paying for expensive drinks ordered by a woman he met, leading to an immediate confrontation and public embarrassment. This action conflicts directly with general social expectations of hospitality or paying for what one orders, especially after initiating the interaction by offering to buy drinks. His subsequent refusal to reimburse the cost, despite pressure from his mother, solidifies his position that his actions were justified in the moment.

Did the OP have a right to dramatically alter the agreement after the drinks were ordered, or does the social contract of offering to buy a drink imply a financial responsibility for what is ordered? Should the OP repay the full cost of the drinks ($325) as his mother requested, or was his decision to walk away and leave a $10 bill the appropriate boundary to set against what he perceived as excessive entitlement?

Categories Uncategorized