AITA for refusing to give up my plane seat so brother and sister could sit together?

After an exhausting day of relentless travel, with two grueling flights and barely a moment to breathe, hope flickered when the passenger found an empty seat beside an older man, offering a rare chance to rest before a crucial job interview. The promise of a few hours of sleep felt like a lifeline amid the chaos of a draining journey and racing thoughts.

But that fragile hope was shattered when the flight attendant asked for their seat to be surrendered so a brother and sister could sit together. Torn between kindness and the desperate need for rest, the traveler faced a heart-wrenching choice, knowing that giving up their seat meant sacrificing the precious sleep they so desperately needed.

AITA for refusing to give up my plane seat so brother and sister could sit together?

I’ve had an all-day trip with two flights, one being 8h and other 10h with 1h40m overlay. I was planned to land at 6:20 AM and had a job interview at my workplace at 9 AM so I really needed to get at least some sleep.

First flight was kind of horrid and I managed to get barely any sleep, and I was kind of dreading the 2nd one already, but I get there and it’s just me and an older man with an empty middle seat in between.

I’m quite tall so this worked perfectly as I could spread my legs and fall asleep nicely. However, flight attendant comes up to me and asks me if I would be open to giving up my seat so brother and sister can sit together (she said they’re young, don’t know how old).

I asked where I’d be moving and she said “Miss, just follow me, I’ll show you everything”. So I thought for a second and realized that wherever she puts me it will be a worse deal than what I have now, and if it was any other situation, I would totally give my seat up, but I REALLY needed to get some rest, so I told her “I’m sorry, I will keep this seat”.

She looked me in shock and said “But they are kids, they would like to sit together, it’s a long flight. Please come with me”, to which I replied “I get that, and I’m sorry, but I’ll stay here”.

She got super annoyed and rolled her eyes, but tbh I was too tired and just drifted away. Once I woken up, the older man said that he hopes couple hours of sleep was worth ruining kids’ flight, but I told him he was free to give up his seat, and he said nothing further.

Anyways, was me not giving up my seat for kids an asshole move? AITA for it?

Here’s how people reacted:

AliceReadsThis

NTA – The whole “I’ll show you” was a big clue that it wasn’t going to be an optimal seat. I wouldn’t be surprised if they were going to settle the kids into your seat while they showed you the other to basically force you to not refuse once you got up.

Flying from Frankfurt to Newark I scored a seat in the front of my section, extra leg room, nothing but a wall in front of me and it was only two seats, aisle and window (I had the aisle). Attendant started to ask if I’d switch seats by playing on emotions, There’s a family that’s separated, I’m sure you know what it’s like traveling with children (actually I don’t), it would be nice for them to sit together. Thing is the kids weren’t separate it was just that one parent had one or two with them and the other parent was a few rows back with the other one or two. I think the attendant figured I’d be moved by their plight and just agree but then I asked the magic question “Where would I be sitting”. She almost kept her poker face and tried to smile like isn’t this wonderful but it slipped a little as she pointed to a seat halfway back in that cabin section, four seats across and I would be in the middle. I refused, she went full on bitch face, I told her thanks but no thanks for a transatlantic flight I’m keeping my leg room and ease of getting up when needed. I get it, you can try and be nice but there has to be a limit between doing a favor and having your experience be more difficult or uncomfortable.

viniciusbfonseca

At first I thought that you’re a bit of TA for not even going to see what the other seat was, but then it got me thinking that if she wasn’t even willing to tell you right then it was most def a worse seat to which you would’ve said no just to come back to your seat and see that the (presumably) kids were already comfy on your place and your bags were already on another overhead.

My dad was in a similar situation once on a flight from London to Shanghai and they wanted him to give his aisle up for one of the middle seats of the 4 seats configuration. He said that he wouldn’t trade for a seat worse then his. After they (airline) really complained and tried to force his hand he said “well, I can see that there are many seats open in business, if it’s really that important I’d be more than happy to give up my seat for one of those, otherwise I’ll be staying here”. Turns out that having a minor seating alone was such a bad thing that they actually gave him the business class seat. Next time they try to force your hand make them a counter and let them be the unreasonable ones

scamp41

NTA there are at least 2 other people they could ask, one being the old guy you were sitting with and the other being the person(s) sitting next to the seat they wanted you to move to. It was probably a middle seat they were trying to move you to, otherwise the flight attendant would have told you what kind of seat it was instead of trying to get you over there first. They obviously thought you wouldn’t move if they gave you the details beforehand.

Edit: thinking about it more, the fact that no one ended up sitting next to you means there were more than likely other options that ended up panning out, so the kids likely ended up sitting next to each other anyway.

WorkingMagpie

NTA
It was going to be NAH until the older man said something to you. He could have just as easily gave up his seat, but no, it was somehow your responsibility as the ‘young woman’ in the equation to be inconvenienced instead of him.

If there’s anyone to blame, it’s the adult who arranged the children’s flight who didn’t want to pay or plan ahead for seats together. They were probably hoping for other people to fix that little detail for them.

TheRealArrowSlit

I see why someone would think badly of you for this. But it’s not like a bus seat. You paid (probably a lot of) money for that seat. And on my honest opinion, you’re not an asshole for not moving. The parents of the kids however…. that’s another story. Who puts their two children on a plane alone, and separates them? Fucking asshole parents imo. NTA
AromaticPeanut

>the older man said that he hopes couple hours of sleep was worth ruining kids’ flight, but I told him he was free to give up his seat, and he said nothing further.

I think this part says it all. NTA, OP. You are not an asshole for wanting to sleep, and the people who tried to make you feel like shit are definitely the assholes.

Edit: A word

lady-neuro

NTA. You paid for that seat, it’s your seat. Why didn’t that guy give up his seat if he felt so strongly about it? I get that it’s two kids, but if it was such a big deal for them to sit together then their parents should’ve bought tickets where they were seated together. You did what you needed to do for your health.
pattisabs

NTA. There are plenty of other people on the plane they could ask to swap, and if the kids are that young they would at least be seated with a parent. You paid for your seat and have every right to keep that seat without being judged. If the old man cared so much, he could give his up.
SilentDegree4

I experience this once.
It was for a transatlantic flight of 12hrs.
But my new seat was first class.
I do not regret giving my seat to a mom with young kid.
Best decision EVER.

So all I can say… just go check out the situation first you might get surprised.

qawsedrf12

NTA

Wow. The attendant basically gave you a command like you had no choice. And didn’t ask the old man?

Good job sticking to your seat, especially when given no compensation

Did anyone end up in the middle seat?

HelenRavenclaw

YTA. Two kids travelled a long lonely flight so you wouldn’t have to have another person sitting near you, a pretty mild discomfort. You sound like a self-centered A who thinks empathy is for other people.
tappytaps

>I told him he was free to give up his seat,

NTA – awesome comeback. It’s great how people are ok with other people being inconvenienced, but not themselves!

ASBF2015

Old guy’s an ass for chirping in, why didn’t the flight attendant ask him? Total bs. I probably would’ve switched, but you’re NTA because you didn’t want to.
Kazayrian

NTA.

You owe no one an apology, you don’t have to move your seats you paid for and the other party (the old man) could’ve given up their seat.

dragonking2812

NAH

Flights suck for everyone, but I can see why it’s kids > adults for some people.

Old man can donate his own seat to charity for all I care.

walahoo

Hahaha good comeback for the dude sitting next to you.. nta imo.
Did they ask the guy? Interesting if the stewardess just picked you to ask..

Conclusion

The original poster (OP) prioritized their urgent need for rest after a long, exhausting travel day to prepare for an important job interview. This action directly conflicted with the flight attendant’s request to accommodate a brother and sister who wished to sit together, leading to judgment from another passenger.

Was the OP justified in prioritizing essential physical recovery for a critical professional event over the comfort and preference of two other passengers? Or did a moral obligation exist to assist the younger travelers, even at the cost of the OP’s necessary sleep?

Categories Uncategorized