AITAH for refusing to pay my wife while we are separated?

In the quiet unraveling of their shared life, a husband bears the weight of silent pain and mounting resentment. His tireless efforts to build a future are met with distance and withdrawal, as his wife drifts through a storm of trauma and confusion, leaving their connection frayed and fragile.

Amidst the chaos of unspoken words and fractured trust, he grapples with the aching reality of loneliness in marriage. The delicate threads of hope hang by a thread, as they navigate counseling sessions and tentative steps forward, each struggling to find a way back to each other in the shadow of crisis.

AITAH for refusing to pay my wife while we are separated?

For context, my wife went through some trauma and has not been using appropriate coping skills or seeking help. Instead, she is going through a complete midlife crisis of sorts, including leaving me rather unexpectedly.

We are in counseling, but as of now she cannot commit to anything other than a walk once a week. We barely speak.

I work THREE JOBS. The original plan was to stack and stack to go travel and possibly foster children eventually. She works one job. I pay all of her and my bills with the exception of her cell phone bill and 1/4 of the car payment.

I was feeling quite resentful, because she had been ignoring all of my messages for about a week. I saw that she was ordering food through a delivery service, so I changed my password.

I saw she was also attempting to buy groceries on a similar app, so I took her off all of them. She then asked me for $150 a week for expenses. I’ve paid it for about a month, and I’m sick of it.

We had talked about going to Greece as a couple. Now, she can’t even commit to more than one walk a week with me and maybe three messages a day. No plan to get back together any time soon.

She says she’s enjoying aspects of being single.

So I’m PISSED. I want to go to Greece by myself to reap the benefits of my hard labor. I stopped paying her. My counselor told me that stopping payment is akin to abuse. But I think that working 3 jobs and sacrificing my mental and physical health so my estranged wife can do god knows what on my dime is also abuse.

I’m standing my ground and not paying her weekly. AITAH? Since I pay all of her other bills this seems quite reasonable. I’m not going to stop paying her bills (except maybe her gym membership..

that’s not essential).

Here’s how people reacted:

ElvieeEcho

NTA. You’re already covering almost all her expenses while she’s choosing to live separately and barely engaging with you. You’re not responsible for funding her single life while working three jobs. If she wants financial support, she should have a conversation about it instead of just expecting it. Going to Greece alone sounds like a well-earned break.

4o

window.__oai_logHTML?window.__oai_logHTML():window.__oai_SSR_HTML=window.__oai_SSR_HTML||Date.now();requestAnimationFrame((function(){window.__oai_logTTI?window.__oai_logTTI():window.__oai_SSR_TTI=window.__oai_SSR_TTI||Date.now()}))

Mysterious_Spark

You are NTA. She should have a reasonable time to transition to living independently but you need to start working out the financial details of your separation now, including her gradual transition off of your financial support. You will feel less stressed about this when you can see the light at the end of the tunnel.

In the process, I hope you can envision a future for yourself that has fewer jobs.

This might be a happier path for both of you, in the long run. It seems that you have been piling too much on yourselves, and maybe did not have a sustainable situation.

DrCueMaster

Your wife is not interested in getting back together with you if she will only walk with you once a week. She’s enjoying aspects of being single? Cool. See how she like paying for all her stuff, like single people do. Lock down your credit, NOW, and move whatever money you think is yours to another account. And then get a divorce attorney. When you do this, she may decide that her crisis is over and she wants to be your loving wife again. Just remember how she is now is who she really is.
Puzzleheaded-Mix1270

Here’s the thing, if you’re legally separated they look at the total income from your last year. If you make more than her, you will be court ordered to pay her to maintain the standard of living. This you can get in hit water for not doing. Getting married without a prenup has its downfalls.

So while you’re not TAH for not wanting to pay her, you may end up having to do so anyways. Why are you guys even in counseling if she doesn’t even want to get back together?!

Over_Average3567

Oh boo freaking hoo. Death happens. Both my dad and brother died UNEXPECTEDLY and I am still able to be a full functioning adult and leaned into my husband. She’s using you while being single. She’s keeping you on the line so she can do whatever she wants and still have her life funded. STAND UP GUY! It’s time to take yourself on a nice vacation, cut that dead weight loose and seriously get a new therapist.
cthulularoo

She wants all the perks of being single without any of the responsibilities. Which means you get lumped with all the disadvantages of being married without the perks.

Yeah no, she can totally enjoy single life. But that means not having a husband pay for everything. If she complains just tell her you’re supporting her journey into single life.

You’re not being abusive, you’re just supportive.

CapraCat

What is the end goal here? Pay for an estranged wifes bills forever? If the relationship can’t be repaired why stay together on paper? If there’s a prenup I would cut your losses and move on. They are taking advantage of you and your therapist is giving stupid advice. Taking care of yourself is not abusing your estranged spouse. She’s more than capable of taking care of herself.
Dragon_Bidness

NTA

I say this as a lesbian housewife, she ain’t entitled to shit. Get the damn divorce and move on. There’s plenty of people out there who will want you and will spend time, money and effort on you.

Your mistake is staying with someone who is with you to get her bills paid.

Relevant_Demand7593

NTA, you are separated and do not have children. She’s not your responsibility anymore.

If she is enjoying being single then she should get the full experience. Bills and all.

I feel like she’s stringing you along so she can be single and have her bills paid.

Subject-Shoulder-240

It doesn’t really matter if there’s an AH or not. What do the laws in whatever state you’re married in look like? If youve been married for more than a handful of years you’ll likely have to pay alimony since the martial lifestyle had you paying all of her bills.
Certain_Detective_84

This is lawyer territory, not Reddit territory. Cutting her off prior to the divorce is likely to look bad to a judge and be more expensive in the long run. You can’t DIY reducing the amount you spend on her without at least talking to a divorce lawyer.
GlitterAndGhastly

Talk to a lawyer. If she’s been reliant upon you for food, shelter, clothing, and essentials, then in many places of the world, you’ll need to pay support.

In the US, denying her money for food while you’re the primary breadwinner is akin to abuse.

ExtraLengthiness5551

Dump your therapist. Dump the wife, I’m sorry that sounds harsh..but if your post is true those should be your next steps. She has a job and if she wants to play single lady, single ladies pay their own way.

Enjoy Greece it’s beautiful. NTA

Ordinary-Concern3248

I mean – your wife went through trauma and, in your opinion, isn’t using her “appropriate coping skills.”
Clearly since you know how she should cope with whatever it is better than her, you could never be the AH 🙄
mcmurrml

You need to get a lawyer. She isn’t going to work out anything with you. She works full time she can buy her own food. I assume no kids? She wants to be single so let her. It is not to your benefit to drag this out.
Competitive-Week-935

What the hell is wrong with everyone. She went through trama. Love how you gloss that over, she’s not using her coping skills. Like the trauma is her fault. WTF? No wonder she won’t go anywhere with you.
VanityQueen90

It’s 2024 and women love that feminism. She can pay for herself and it’s not abuse. It’s so exhausting to hear that honestly and I am a woman. lol cut her off. You know what’s abuse? What she’s doing to YOU.
Full_Pace7666

Your therapist fucking sucks. Get a new one.

But OP, it sounds like your marriage is over and it might be worth lawyering up and separating legally if she has zero intention of working it outz

NTA

Duchess_Witch

I would call a lawyer, hire said lawyer, and file for divorce. Your lawyer will handle everything including any obligated payments- if any. Stop communicating with her effectively now.
Less_Instruction_345

NTA. She has no intention of getting back with you. You are now her personal ATM. Get a lawyer, file for divorce and use your hard earned money to do the things YOU want to do.
SDBlue68

NTA, this sounds familiar to me. My ex would do this. After we divorced, I found out she was cheating during the separation. In her mind it was ok because we’re separated.
Zealousideal_Fail_83

She is a gold digger. She wants none other responsibility and all of the benefits of your money.

So she likes the single life, cool.

Let her have it as soon as possible.

DownShatCreek

NTA. Drop your counselor immediately and report them to their regulatory body. Unless they’re unregulated where you are, which would explain a lot.
facinationstreet

*My counselor told me that stopping payment is akin to abuse.*

You need a new counselor and a divorce lawyer.

These_Hair_193

Cut her off. She’s not entitled to anything. Once she leaves, the money dries up. She knows that.
greyhounds4life1969

Stop sending her money and send her divorce papers instead, the marriage is probably dead.
r_husba

Go to Greece! Dude, it’s so cheap. Meteora is incredible… forget your wife & just go
82jon1911

NTA. Councilor is shit. I would lawyer up, doesn’t sound like this is being fixed.
seaxvereign

>She says she’s enjoying aspects of being single.

Then make her single.

NTA

Mental-Pin-8594

Nta. She’s seeing someone else!!! File for divorce! Cut her off!
peakpenguins

NTA, talk to a divorce lawyer and get a new counselor.
Lost_Needleworker285

This sounds like a very poor legal move
One_Dragonfly_9698

NTA. You have zero obligation here
Alexcanfuckoff

It is considered financial abuse.
Hidden_Vixen21

Your therapist is not your ally.
Welshcat_lady2015

Go to Greece and get a divorce

Conclusion

The original poster is experiencing intense anger and resentment due to the significant financial and physical sacrifices made while their estranged wife is seemingly avoiding necessary trauma recovery and expressing enjoyment in single life. The central conflict arises from the OP’s decision to immediately halt discretionary weekly financial support in response to this situation, a move their counselor labeled as potentially abusive.

Considering the OP’s extreme work ethic supporting both parties versus the wife’s current lack of commitment to recovery and the relationship, is the OP justified in immediately stopping the $150 weekly allowance, or does this action cross a line into punitive or abusive behavior, especially when they continue to cover all other essential household expenses?

Categories Uncategorized