AITAH for wanting simple divorce because I am not ready to take my husband’s orphan siblings?

The original poster (OP), a 24-year-old woman, is married to her 24-year-old husband. They met at university, married at 21, and she runs a bridal store while he runs a hardware shop.

Two months ago, the couple’s lives changed drastically when the husband’s parents died in an accident, leaving behind two young siblings (aged 12 and 10) and debt due to poor investments. The husband took in his younger siblings, which derailed the couple’s plans to save for a house and start a family around age 27. Feeling overwhelmed by the sudden responsibility and realizing she does not want a family life right now, the OP asked for a divorce and moved out, leaving her feeling selfish yet resolute.

AITAH for wanting simple divorce because I am not ready to take my husband's orphan siblings?

I am 24f and my husband 24, both met at our university, when we both were 18. Got married at age of 21. I run a bridal store and he runs a hardware shop.

My husband has two siblings who are 12 and 10, as his parents struggled fertility issues for a decade and then had two children later. His parents died two months back in an accident.

And left a house but not much money, due to bad investments.

My husband took his siblings in and I respect him for that. But it isn’t something that I signed up for at such a young age.

Our whole budget has gone to toss and he will be responsible for their education and other things in future. Yes we both earn well. But still expensive foreign trips, my high end lifestyle and other things need money.

Our own plan was to have three years of marriage and plan a child around age of 27.

I realized it won’t be something I want at this point with too much household work and two kids to care for. I asked for divorce. And has moved out.

There are not much assets as we were saving for a house. And I will grant him an easy divorce. I love him, but I am selfish and at 24. I don’t want to do all this. I want to travel and live my life.

It hurts, but this isn’t something I want.

I have moved out and he is asking me to solve this. I can’t ask him to give away his siblings to other relatives or social care. I am not that horrible person. But I also don’t want to be responsible for them.

My parents and siblings are saying that hardships are part of life and I should give my marriage a chance. I don’t know. I know I will be very resentful if I force myself into this.

Here’s how people reacted:

sptfire

NTA. everybody is losing in this scenario and I applaud OP for realizing that she would be a shit parent/sister. She understands her limitations. And she is right, the traditional vows are ‘Do you promise to love, honor, and cherish them, in sickness and in health, for as long as you both shall live..’ She kept her vows and they both married with the understanding that here would be no children for several years.

She isn’t walking away from biological children, and while she loves her husband, this isn’t the life she signed up for. Whether she regrets her choices down the line, well she is the only one who has to live with it. She isn’t asking him give up his siblings. This is the right thing for HIM to do, not her. This is a fork in the road for them. I would be no different if hubby got a job in another country and she didn’t want to leave everything she had built for herself and her business.

Major life changes for partners mean someone in the relationship has to give up something. She chooses to give up the marriage instead of her dreams. u/[BrokenDreams147](https://www.reddit.com/user/BrokenDreams147/), this sucks for everyone, but you have every right to walk away. He doesn’t want to do this alone while the three of them are still grieving the loss of their parents and you doesn’t have to set yourself on fire to keep him warm.

509RhymeAnimal

NTA but honestly you shouldn’t have gotten married in the first place, you are by no means ready to compromise and do the kind of on the fly adjustments that life demands when you’re in a relationship. If this isn’t the life you want to live than that’s your prerogative. If two children are a deal breaker that’s your prerogative. You are NTA.

Tell him there’s nothing to work out because at the end of the day he’s responsible for his siblings and that’s a good thing, it’s great and wonderful that he’s taking care of his siblings but that’s not where you’re at right now with your life so for both of your sakes you’re going to go ahead and call the relationship over.

I hope you don’t look back and regret the decision, I think you will but again, it’s your prerogative to end the relationship if it’s no longer working for you.

Ghostgrl94

I do not understand all the YTA here. Op you are NOT TA for recognizing that you arent in a place to have kids yet. Forcing you into a role you arent ready for will ONLY lead to indifference and fester resentment. People forget op is only 24 and had plans to start a family at 27. You can break up with your partner for any reason and just because you are married doesnt change that. People can decide to not be a step parent to their partner’s family. Op you are NTA. Kids, let alone other people’s kids, are a big responsibility.
Finngrove

Better to be upfront and honest now than become miserable and resentful. You were both young when you married and not ready for a full family yet. Don’t the children deserve to be in a family feeling wanted and loved? You are doing the right thing by them. Divorce and go your separate ways. Fall in love with other people just make a clean break though, do not expect him to remain your friend or depend on him to be your helpmate. If you give him up, give up what you love about the relationship and do not toy with him.
Aimeebernadette

NAH – your husband expecting your support is understandable but you also didn’t sign on to raise two nearly-teens when you’re barely out of your teens yourself and are just starting your career. Especially when you add in that men don’t really help with childcare where you live – your husband wants you to stay to be free childcare and that is out of line. You’ve done the right thing for you and that’s what matters.
Character-Food-6574

You’re right about not having made a commitment to his family,and you’re right for being honest with yourself and your spouse. It isn’t what he wants, but this situation is neither what you want, nor what you’re prepared to do. You’re doing the right thing by being honest about your feelings and your unwillingness to immediately and permanently parent his siblings.
TheBrainKnowsBest

There are a lot of folks who seem to think it’s your duty to do all of this. You’re NTA. The terms of your marriage changed and it’s not a given that you need to take care of his family. It’s a gift and you’re not obligated to give it and have very good reasons for not doing so.

Ignore those trying to guilt trip you. You have the right to secure boundaries.

Past-Anything9789

NTA – it may be really harsh, especially as he has lost his parents too, but at the end of it all, this is your choice.
If you don’t want the responsibility both financially and literally then it is your perogative to walk away.

People will judge you for it, but they aren’t the ones in your position at such a young age. If it’s not for you, then stand firm.

3littlepixies

Basically: “I want a family – but not THAT family.”, “I want kids but not THOSE kids.”

Leave him. He and the kids don’t deserve to be resented the rest of their lives. Which is exactly what you will do if you have to raise kids you don’t want to raise. Who knows how you’ll treat them when you start having biological children. Leave and stay away from them.

Chefmeatball

NTA, but you might be being a bit rash (I don’t know the timeline). Your husband is also probably grieving, so you should at least be there for him. Those were part of your vows (as you stated). I’m not saying give it more time so that you’ll feel different, but give it more time so that your husband doesn’t have to deal with another bomb blowing up his life
Positively_Me_

Important to know the person you marry so you don’t end up with a selfish , uh, person, I’ll be nice, more interested in traveling and a high end lifestyle than having a family, lol. Let me know how that turns out when you’re ancient and alone and nobody will marry you anymore. 😂
sindyisdatchu

NTA. Because of the fact you say that you in a Third World country and you are the one who supposed to be responsible to take care of them not the man !!!!he should be in consideration !it’s his sibling , he should plan and men don’t do ,the rest of the time so I am on your side
gentleman190

YTA to abandon your husband at this point. It’s pretty much the definition of being an asshole to abandon someone just when the going gets bit rough. There is no talking yourself out of it – it makes you a bad person.

But perhaps it’s choice you need to make.

Terrible_Feeling_925

DO NOT FEEL GUILTY!!! No matter what some of the comments in here say. – We only get one life. Taking care of kids is not what you signed up for. — (Parenthood is HUGE DEAL. And hard!!!!)… If it’s not something you want, then divorce…. NTA!!!!!!!
isabgol_isabgol

NTA, girl live girl life the way you see it fit. We don’t have to live with your decision. Plus, 2 preteen kids in your early 20s isn’t a joke, you’re basically giving up your youth. I’d make the same decision as you.
Id_rather_be_sewing

NTA this is your life and your decision. You would be giving up your best years to raise children you don’t want. That will negatively impact the children as well. The only one who won’t be miserable is your husband.
montauk6

 *expensive foreign trips,* ***my high end lifestyle*** *and other things need money*

So much for “for richer or for poorer, in sickness and in health…”

Are YOU the AH….? Welp… if you have to ask………

summa-time-gal

I wouldn’t say you are the asshole. You know what you want and what you don’t want.
Hubby stepped up for HIS siblings , but you didn’t

Feel for you. But. I probably in your shoes would have done the same.

Ok_Mango_6887

NTA

Taking on two preteens at your age is a huge responsibility – you have the right to change your mind on marriage if it’s completely changed from what you signed up for. Two kids under 12 is a huge change.

Clean_Permit_3791

NAH you have the right to whatever life you want for yourself. It’s a really sad situation but if you don’t want to do it you don’t have to and if you can live without him then I guess you just move on 
Itakesyourbases

No. In fact this is a very amicable reason to break up. Life is about death, space and taxes. If you don’t wanna share one of those with anyone whatever paracasual “morals” there are. is IRRELEVANT
CurrentTea3987

You’re just 24. You still haven’t lived and to be burdened with children that aren’t yours is wild. Get out while you can. It’s a crappy situation but it’s not your situation
that-mystical-ginger

Absolutely YTA. You’re a terrible person and the only upside is that your husband and the kids will obviously be better off without someone so selfish in their lives.
BadFish7763

Those kids didn’t do anything to deserve their situation. They need someone in this world to love them. You are too selfish to be that someone, so go. YTA
peaceandquiet59

NTA. It’s just an unfortunate situation and you are not required to give up your life for his siblings. Better to leave than to stay and be resentful.
Present_Amphibian832

You know you. If you cannot deal with the kids, do what you need to. It does NOT make you an AH for knowing your limitations. Good luck
drillthisgal

I support you. That is a lot to take on.You are really young. I couldn’t handle that responsibility at that age.
OpportunityCalm6825

NTA for wanting to live a life just the way you wanted. It sounds cruel but it is inevitable.
QuietRiot7222310

He’s better off with you gone. You’re definitely the ass, but probably saving him.
Difficult-Double8018

It’s better you left, bcz all the work will go on you and you’re just 24!
ahop4200

“High end lifestyle” hope he divorces you real soon what a lady 🤦‍♂️
rayeranhi

NAH Healthier for the kids to not have a mom who doesn’t want them.
peabuddie

I like that you’re honest, with yourself and with him.
MindlessApricot8

NAH. It’s your life, and yours to spend as you wish.
Bistec-Chef

Leave, he will eventually find a better person.
Slinkman13

NTA and after the edit even more so
UltimatePragmatist

NTA. I wouldn’t do it, either.

Conclusion

The OP is currently in a difficult position, torn between her love for her husband and her strong desire to maintain the young, independent lifestyle she envisioned for herself, especially as she feels ill-equipped and unwilling to take on the role of caretaker for his younger siblings at this stage of her life.

The central conflict lies in whether personal life goals and freedom override marital commitment when an unforeseen, shared tragedy dramatically alters the established partnership structure. Should the OP proceed with the divorce to protect her future autonomy, or should she stay, accepting the parental role her husband has embraced, despite the risk of future resentment?

Categories Uncategorized