AITAH for telling my ex wife she cannot forbid me from walking her daughter down the aisle just because I cheated on her

The Original Poster (OP) was married to his ex-wife for fourteen years, during which time he formed a strong paternal relationship with her daughter, the stepdaughter. The marriage ended a couple of years ago due to the OP admitting to infidelity, an action for which he takes full responsibility.

Surprisingly, the cheating did not damage the relationship between the OP and his stepdaughter, who maintained that their bond was separate from her parents’ adult issues. When the stepdaughter recently asked the OP to walk her down the aisle at her upcoming wedding, the request was met with strong disapproval from the ex-wife, leading to a direct confrontation between the OP and his ex-wife. The central question is whether the OP has the right to attend this significant family event despite the ex-wife’s clear objections stemming from their past marital issues.

AITAH for telling my ex wife she cannot forbid me from walking her daughter down the aisle just because I cheated on her

My ex wife and I divorced a couple years ago. We were married for 14 years and during that time, I also developed a strong bond with her daughter. However, my ex wife and I divorced a couple years ago after I cheated on her.

I take full responsibility for it and don’t really have any excuses for it. I still regret it to this day, and I know it really hurt my ex wife a lot.

I really thought this would affect my bond with my stepdaughter and I was even prepared for her to go no contact with me. However, it didn’t affect my bond with her at all, and my step daughter said it’s adult business and it doesn’t change that I’ve been a father figure for her for more than a decade.

Last month, my step daughter told me she was getting married next year and asked me to walk her down the aisle. I was really honored with this privilege but I asked her if her mom would be ok with it.

She said her mom wasn’t ok with it all, and did not even want me at wedding. I asked my step daughter if she was sure me being at the wedding wouldn’t cause any additional drama, and my step daughter said she didn’t care what others thought as she knew how much of a great father figure I was to her.

I was really happy but also emotional, and I said sure. However, a couple days later, my ex wife called and told me I shouldn’t attend the wedding, and that no one wanted me at the wedding.

I told my ex wife to not make her daughter’s wedding about her, and it didn’t matter what others thought as long as the bride wanted me at the wedding. I told my ex wife she cannot forbid me from attending her daughter’s wedding just because I cheated on her.

Here’s how people reacted:

astoldbybeja

Idk. I’d go with ESH, if I’m being honest, if I was the ex-wife, I’d feel completely betrayed by my own daughter and couple that with the ex-husband that absolutely betrayed me, I’d skip it altogether.

IMO, I do think you’re the AH OP. Being an adulterer is not a small matter now you’re driving a wedge between a mother and her child when in actuality, you shouldn’t even be in the equation let alone a consideration.

I certainly hope the bride to be finds your presence there worth it cause I don’t see your ex wife and her coming back from something like this. I know I personally wouldn’t, I’d actually be damned. Anyways, good luck OP.

NumbersOverFeelings

NTA.

Too many N.AH’s here. This sub has repeatedly agreed that the wedding belongs to the bride (minutely to the groom; somewhat unfair but that’s a different argument). The ex wife doesn’t have any right to dictate her daughter’s wedding even if she paid (as this sub has confirmed you can’t use your money to hold over your kid’s head). Her calling and meddling in the wedding plans makes her an AH to her daughter.

The step daughter wants you there OP. You go if you want to walk her down the aisle but be ready for dagger stares and ignore them. Remember to not ruin your step daughter’s day no matter what.

Amandamargret

I think you need to talk to your ex in a honest way about how you want to respect both her wishes and her daughter’s. But you’re not sure how to accomplish it in this situation. Ask your ex what boundaries could be set that could make it amicable. Do you walk her down the aisle and not attend the reception or dance? Are you only in pictures with the bride and groom? Do you attend alone? What compromises can be made for sake of her daughter’s special day. Remind your ex that her daughter asked you to walk her down the aisle, not the other way around, and you would be honored.
JJQuantum

Your ex certainly can’t forbid you from being at the wedding or walking her daughter down the aisle. The issue is between your ex and her daughter. However, you’ve brought enough pain into their relationship with your cheating already and don’t need to bring more when you could help their relationship by simply not going, and taking the blame for not going instead of blaming your ex. The relationship that’s most important here is between those 2. You’ve caused your ex enough pain. Take responsibility for your actions and don’t cause her any more. YTA.
daisybabybell

NTA.
Your stepdaughter’s a grown woman and she’s made it clear she wants you to walk her down the aisle. It’s her wedding, not your ex’s, and she gets to decide who’s important enough to be there.

Yeah, cheating sucks and I get why your ex is still upset, but that doesn’t undo the bond you’ve had with her daughter for years. Your ex is making it about her own feelings, when it should be about what her daughter wants. If the bride’s cool with it, that’s really all that matters OP

svohorder

Not the asshole. For everyone jumping on his daughter and his connection when he’s not blood but is father figure, have you thought maybe he was the more stabile parent and that is her anchor? Like the bride said, it’s adult business. My ex stepmom was the stable one for most of my hs and college life and when they divorced she was still my rock. And since she’s since cut me off, I can def see why the daughter shouldn’t have to break off that bond
ConsequenceLow4177

NTA, you were exactly right when you said it only matters that your step daughter (bride) wants you at the wedding. Unfortunately although you Ex is obviously against this, she will just have to suck it the fuck up and be ok with it for her daughters sake. So happy for your sake that your step daughter is able to put things in perspective and see her relationship with you separately from the issues with your Ex as well, so very mature of her.
Top-Monitor5275

YATAH Good for the parenting and relationship with your step daughter. Your presence at the wedding will drive a wedge between the daughter and her mother possibly forever. You can have a great relationship with the daughter without humiliating your ex. at the wedding. You know all the guests know what happened with your marriage. Do not attend and tell the daughter why.
MarionberryOk2874

I can understand why your ex is upset about this, but the BRIDE wants you there! if mom has an issue with it, she needs to take it up with her daughter. I bet she won’t tho, because then she’ll be faced with the fact that she thinks her feelings about you are more important than her daughter’s wishes for her wedding…not a great ‘Mom’ moment…NTA
CookMoist4494

It’s honestly a sad situation all around and I feel for your ex. Her daughter IS actively choosing her cheating husband over her. Why couldn’t the mom have been the one to walk her daughter down the aisle? I don’t think OPs the ah for going through with it. I think the daughter is. I would never do that to my mom. 
momofdragons2

You should consider your ex-wife’s feelings and back away. You’ve already caused her enough pain, and this is HER daughter. You can do something for her and her new husband privately after the wedding. You being there could really damage her relationship with her mother.
Mjukplister

Given the fact that this will cause a HUGE bust between your Ex and her daughter the most gracious thing would be to gracefully decline and step back , with love . Your ex has suffered enough already because of your actions and it’s her daughter at the end of the day
BravePerspective9598

Sincere question from a non-American: how is it even possible that so many young couples opt for the woman to be traded from one man to the other in a wedding ceremony? It is considered rather outdated, square and misogynistic in Central Europe.
MashaLavender

It’s the girl’s wedding and she should have what she wants. I get her though. I was closer to my late Stepfather than I was to my Mother because he and I were more alike. Both he AND my late Mom walked me down the aisle.
Full-Construction932

And you walking her down the aisle is you “taking full responsibility for your actions”? It is your step daughter’s day but attending is only going to cause more damage. Doesn’t sound like you give a shit about the ex.
sky_lites

ESH except your ex wife. I’d have gone no contact with my daughter if she was awful enough to still accept the man who cheated on me with such open arms.

You both (you and step daughter) sound like awful people.

Quaranj

NTA – Not for this, anyway.

Your stepdaughter is essentially choosing you over *blood* here.

I’m guessing the mom/ex is a real piece of work. Not that it justifies the cheat but it explains the need for escape.

DarkAgeMonks

I’m going to tell you an honest truth i think you need to hear. You aren’t a good father figure because good father figures don’t destroy their children’s homes and lives by cheating on their mom.
GrizzRich

NTA

Your ex-wife doesn’t have a veto. It’s up to the couple being married to decide who does what. Your step daughter is the one that’ll need to live with the consequences, if there are any.

mrs-poocasso69

I think I’m just not understanding why you asked if her mom would be okay with it if you didn’t care either way. Was that just thrown in so it seems like you care about her a little bit?
WatercressAdept4312

The fact that people are saying you’re not the ass hole is hilariously indicative of reddit’s insanely pathetic oracle compass.

You are, undoubtedly, a piece of shit ass hole.

Yiayiamary

I wonder if the ex is being so controlling that the daughter wants to ignore her? Something else going on here. Final thoughts: bride gets first choice, no one else but groom.
BlazedLad98

Honestly a bit creepy tbh you divorced, she’s not your daughter anymore and you still wanna be close to her. Not just that you’re a Redditor, doesn’t help the case much.
CranberrySuper9615

YTA. Can’t even stay faithful to her mom but your gonna walk her down the isle. If I were the mom I’d skip the wending. Then when the in-laws asked why, I’d tell them.
maxdps_

Yeah, you are an asshole for cheating and it’s obviously you lack self-awareness too.

Your the ex. That’s her daughter, not yours.

FlyByNight250

“Just because” LMAO, you ruined your family and say “just because”. No wonder you cheated, your mind is in the wrong place guy.
Ludwig_Vista2

“Her daughter”… you’ve said all you need to, right there.

Also, you cheated.

YTA. You gave up any say you might have had.

Neihananz

NTA but with this, the relationship between your daughter an ex will just be in ruins, so make sure to think this through
Pure-Equivalent2561

YTA, it’s her daughter not yours. The daughter should not invite you to the wedding it’s a betrayal of her mother
realnrh

NTA for the wedding specifically, where the bride has the say. But YTA forever for cheating in the larger scope.
gobledegerkin

How would you feel if your daughter’s future husband put her in the same position you are putting your ex in?
Sharp-Visual2536

You didn’t respect your own marriage. You should be fucking embarrassed to be involved in anyone’s wedding.
No_Ingenuity8206

The people on OP’s side are cheaters hoping they’re not cut off due to their despicable behavior.
10XL

If you actually regret cheating on your ex to this day, you wouldn’t attend the wedding.
JumpStart2002

If I was the ex wife I’d go no contact with the daughter , like what the hell.
Antique-Dragonfly615

It SHOULD be the brides choice. Everyone else can F off.
Maleficent-Flow2828

Her daughter is TA, that is a weird af thing to do
OmegaPointMG

Step daughter giving you grace. YTA for cheating.
GirthQuake5040

NTA but tbh the daughter is the ass.

Conclusion

The OP is currently facing a conflict where his deeply valued role as a father figure to his stepdaughter clashes directly with the boundaries and emotional comfort of his ex-wife, who is still affected by his past betrayal. The OP believes his relationship with the bride should take precedence over the ex-wife’s desire to exclude him from the event.

The core debate centers on balancing the emotional needs and established roles within a blended family following a divorce caused by infidelity. Should the stepdaughter’s wishes for a specific parent figure override the ex-wife’s right to dictate who is present at her daughter’s wedding, or does the ex-wife have the authority to exclude the person who caused her significant pain from this major family milestone?

Categories Uncategorized