AITA for refusing to try on hijab?

A 26-year-old female PhD student in the UK, who is an atheist, shares a living space with her 28-year-old Muslim roommate. The relationship, generally accommodating with the OP respecting the roommate’s religious needs, recently fractured over a request involving religious dress.

The roommate insisted the OP participate in a ‘hijab makeover’ practice session, which the OP politely refused, citing personal disinterest. The roommate reacted strongly, accusing the OP of Islamophobia and subsequently ceasing communication and reportedly spreading negative claims about the OP to others on campus, leaving the OP fearful of academic repercussions.

AITA for refusing to try on hijab?

I (26 F) am aware that this is an incredibly controversial topic but I am at my wits end in this situation and my family and friends are overseas and mostly incapable of helping me due to inexperience and lack of awareness.

I am in the UK for my PhD and my roommate (28F) is muslim. We usually get along very well and I have been respectful and accommodating of her religious practices. I am very aware of the rising islamophobia worldwide and try to advocate against it whenever I can.

I feel the need to mention these things because they become relevant. I am an atheist myself. My roommate on numerous occasions has tried to discuss religion and theology with me, but I have quickly shut her down fearing that this may lead to a conflict due to our differences.

After her several attempts of comparing our respective religious backgrounds, I firmly told her that religion is that one topic I don’t want to remotely touch in a conversation with her because I did not want an argumentative and tense relationship with someone I share a roof with and she understood and stopped.

Everything was fine for months until she started following those drives on tiktok where people get a hijab makeover on the streets and look pretty and thought of doing such a drive of her own.

I gave her a thumbs up and moved on until she said she wanted to practice on me. I told her that I am not comfortable with this. She told me it is just a piece of cloth and it won’t hurt to try because I may end up liking it.

I firmly told her that while that is absolutely alright, I don’t want to try it on, because I am simply not interested. This went on back and forth for some time until she told me that she is glad my islamophobia is finally out in the open and I have exposed myself.

I was shocked and I asked her what made her think that I am an Islamophobe based on this one incident when I have gone above and beyond for her comfort. I abide by all her dietary restrictions in our shared kitchen despite not having any such restriction of my own.

Once I bought this beautiful statue of a Hindu Goddess (not for worshipping purposes but purely for aesthetic reasons) and she told me that she was uncomfortable with the violent figure.

I immediately complied and packed it away without any argument. I profusely apologised to her and I told her that I have nothing against hijab just because I don’t want it on me. She stopped talking to me altogether after that.

A couple of other people on the campus have reported that she is telling everyone how uncomfortable she is sharing a place with someone so hateful towards her religion. While I am hurt that I have lost a friend overnight, I am also extremely scared that the word may reach the university administration and they might take disciplinary action against me.

I may lose my scholarship or maybe thrown out of college altogether. I am an international student and this would mean my career will be completely over. I don’t know what to do or how to explain my end of the story because no one seems interested.

I have continuously and unconditionally apologised to her since the event but nothing seems to work. Could anyone tell me where did I exactly go wrong and how can I fix this situation?

Here’s how people reacted:

Temporary-Chef207

As a former Muslim+hijabi myself, one with plenty of practicing hijabi friends, I can tell you that at no point in my life have I ever insisted on someone “trying on” hijab for whatever reason and then taken it personally when they refused. And the same goes for the aforementioned hijabi friends. In fact, I think any practicing hijabi with a modicum of sense should have a better awareness of how the hijab and modesty is policed in our own communities, and that there are plenty of negative connotations with forcing/coercing someone to put it on.

If everything is the way you say it is, I hope your college has the sense to see there’s nothing oppressive or Islamophobic about refusing to wear a piece of clothing you don’t agree with yourself, even if you respect another person’s choice to wear it. It’s not the same as modeling for something else either; there’s an ideological component to the hijab and you can be unaligned with it without being an Islamophobe. Kinda funny your roommate’s so quick to spy Islamophobia anyway when she can’t even adjust to a Hindu representation that no one’s forcing her to pray to. She doesn’t sound particularly tolerant of other worldviews honestly.

Quimeraecd

Atheist here. You did nothing wrong. NTA. Do realize that wearing a Jihab has no significance to You and a Lot for her. And this is Jihab make over thing is important for your friend.

You could have, but were in no way obliged to, wrap a piece of clothing around your head to for a few minutes. It didnt hurt You and your friend would have been happy.

When i was younger, I was more adamant about not allowing others to included me in their religious practices. Nowadays I understand them as cultural practices, I don’t mind any more, especially if is for Friends, as long as i’m not forced to do anything.

In any event she is the asshole. Not wanting to be part of a religious practices is not hatred towards that practices.

WittyCan6527

The hijab is an hilarious form of Stockholm syndrome oppression. Rules created by men long after Muhammed or Jesus were gone so that these fragile men could protect their property (read:women family members) and so no other man could look upon them lest they lust after their property. Burkas, hijabs, etc they’re all varying levels of the same oppression wearing the guise of goofy religions intentions created by seedy men claiming to have religious backing. And if you don’t believe me, then look up what they do to Muslim women that remove their coverings in protest. Spoiler alert, they beat, torture, rape, and kill them for their sins. Such a Quran inspired reaction no?
kittykat_sorcery

NTA – You have every right to set boundaries over your personal comfort, and politely declining to wear a hijab doesn’t make you Islamophobic.\*\* This situation seems to be about differing perspectives and personal boundaries rather than discrimination. You’ve shown respect toward your roommate’s beliefs and lifestyle, and it’s unfair for her to mislabel you over this disagreement.If you’d like, I can help draft a message or explain how to approach your university or others involved in a calm, factual way to clear up the misunderstanding.
loovelyxxfemme

You’re NTA. You politely declined something you were uncomfortable with, and your roommate’s reaction was completely inappropriate and unfair. It’s her right to wear a hijab, and it’s your right not to. Her accusations of Islamophobia are baseless and damaging…

Document everything that has happened including her accusations to others. If the university contacts you, calmly explain your side of the story emphasizing your respect for her beliefs and your right to decline to participate in something you’re not comfortable with.

Sinusayan

NTA, she absolutely is, as she’s trying to force her religion on you. There are even debates about whether or not the hijab is necessary to practice Islam. Considering how many women don’t have the right to show their hair, you absolutely should not be forced to wear one in a country where you do have the freedom to wear what you want.

Muslims don’t drink and believe homosexuality is a sin. You’re not “Islamophobic” if you are gay and drink. Your roommate has just learned how to get what she wants by throwing out that word.

HabeebTC

Now listen. I am miles away from understanding these women’s life experiences and perspectives. That said…

…But I feel like the roommate’s reaction was some 20 yo social media addict type of reaction, looking for anything to be able to create drama. Very little (if anything) to do with her religion.

I have opted out of all kinds of suggested religious rites when visiting churches and temples. Nobody ever gave me crap about it. It’s called mutual respect.

Future_Direction5174

Tell her that if you wear a hijab then you would be disrespecting her religion. You have nothing against wearing a head-scarf but not a hijab as that has a cultural significance, and a non-believer wearing one could be deemed cultural appropriation.

It is the equivalent of you insisting that she removes her hijab so that men can see her hair. Tell her if she agrees to remove her hijab and come with you to a coffee shop for one hour, then you will do it.

MrEdinLaw

Ah yes, the muslim acceptance.

Im an ex muslim and am still around muslims 99% of my time.

I had my fair share of forced prayers and stuff, and it always came out the same way.

Trust, she was just waiting to force you on something and blow up on you. Even if u did nothing, it would be your fault anyway.

Sorry to say, but most Muslims aren’t even compatible in between each other. Additionally, they hate atheists and thats just It.

Organic-Mix-9422

NTA. You don’t want to wear a hijab. End of story. Ask her to wear a short sleeved shirt for you. Or a dress down to her knees . It makes her uncomfortable, hello same thing back at her. Tell everyone else having a go at you that they can wear it instead.

She is absolutely allowed to wear what she wants, but not to enforce it on you.

I also would stop catering to her decisions on the decor in your shared space.

Illustrious_March192

I would think you need to go to the university administrator yourself asap and tell them the situation you’re in. Follow up with an email or something so there will be a paper trail.

It wouldn’t be right for you to force any type of Christian things on anyone and it’s not right for any other religion to be forced on you. You have went above and beyond for this girl. Sounds to me that she wants to be your victim

igramigru101

Nta. There’s no thing as Islamophobia. Phobia is irrational fear. When people are aggressively push their agenda, there’s no phobia. If I were you, I’d start wearing jewelry with cross, or whatever symbol uses religion of your ancestors. Just a warning. There’s no peace with religious zealots. You either succumb or fight with tooth and nails. No middle ground.
catxxseduuctive

You did nothing wrong. Your roommate’s accusations are unfair. Document everything. Talk to the university *first* about what happened. Emphasize your respect for all religions and your right to decline. Seek support from a counselor. Don’t engage with your roommate on this. Know your university’s policies. You have the right to say no.
evil_regal031

NTA AT ALL

You are very well within your right to refuse ANYTHING that makes you uncomfortable. Your roommate is being completely unreasonable and if you want and it ever goes to administration, tell them she made you pack away a Hindu deiti because she was uncomfortable and you never accused her of Anti-Hindu Sentiment 🤷

IaintGrooot

She seems extremely hard work and seems like she’s trying to force her religious beliefs onto you. Tell her straight she can fuck off. You should of told her a dildo is only a piece of plastic and asked if you can jam it up her ass since some other people like it. Bet she wouldn’t of been happy about that.
StatisticianPlus7834

NTA. You were polite and respectful. Maybe it’s a good idea to go to UNI admin first and talk about it. She is pushing her beliefs on you, making you to submit to her restrictions, and she is not respectful about your belief system. That’s why people have problems regarding any fanatics from any religion!
ZettaiGeek

Get to a UNI admin asap. Le t them know everything that is happening including her threat to falsely accuse you of islamaphobia. Do not allow her to control the narrative in this. Ask for a new roommate as she is making threats and you are no longer comfortable catering to her religious ideals.
NuttPunch

Once she called you islamophobic you should have doubled down on that. You will never win if you continually submit to these people. She’s been testing you from the beginning. She doesn’t respect you or whatever religion you may have. It’s completely hostile and you should match that.
JRDZ1993

NTA, sounds like you’ve bent over backwards to accomodate her religion even where it goes so far as to insist your shared space have nothing even hinting at others. It sounds like she’s been trying to subtley peer pressure you into participating in her faith too.
Thin-Disaster4170

lol. Muslims want to convert you the same way Christians do. Ask her to just go do communion, it’s only crackers and wine it’s not real. He’ll ask her to get baptized while you’re at it. She’s an intolerant asshole. Respect gets respect.
Cookie1107

NTA. You have done nothing wrong. She needs to respect your boundaries. I have no problem with anyones religion, however it really annoys me when it is forced upon others. Your room mate is gaslighting you and sounds extremely toxic.
una_fury

NTA. You were well within your rights to decline your roommate’s request to try on a hijab.Remember, you have done nothing wrong. Stand firm in your position and do not let your roommate’s accusations intimidate you.
lynypixie

NTA

A lot of religious people (not only Muslim) do this thing where they seem friendly at first and slowly try to convert people. She is one of them. It is rampant where i live and it’s becoming problematic.

SuspiciousCustomer

Go to admin and tell them your roommate is disrespectful towards your religion, your religious freedom and trying to convert you and forces her religious beliefs on you.

Don’t wait. Get ahead of it.

Chiskey_and_wigars

Religion should be illegal, or at the very least public displays of religion like prayer, wearing religious garb, or the like. You’re NTA and I’d recommend going hardcore Satanist until she fucks off
RaspberryVivid6504

NTA. What if you wanted to give her a makeover without a hijab on? Would she be all “oh okay fun let’s do it.” Willing to bet not. You were polite and said no thank you. Nothing wrong with that.
twosteppsatatime

None of the Muslims I know would ever try something like this. She is just playing victim and probably loves drama. The way she behaves doesn’t seem to align with her believes honestly.
SmokedOkie

Stay strong and steadfast, don’t bend the knee to any religious group attempting to force a standard of any kind, you are a free Human before all else.
SleestakkLightning

NTA not Islamaphobic even remotely. The fact that she’s gaslighting you when you’re clearly uncomfortable is insane. You should change room mates
MorteDagger

NTA. Go to admin and tell them she is pushing your to wear hijab and that your uncomfy about her constant pressure to try one.
zikreezain

As a Muslim myself, your room mate is definitely crossing the line. We don’t push people for our believe and vice versa.
EarthBelcher

NTA. But. Get ahead of this and make reports to the university that she is spreading lies about you.
PipeComfortable2585

You need to get another roommate. And confront her before you do about her conversations
TwoJacksAndAnAce

She’s trying to convert you, the slow way. I hate this shit, forcing religion on people
Ok-Zookeepergame2196

It’s not Islamophobia if you’re calling out shitty actions by people practicing Islam…
Necessary_One_2590

She was trying to convert you, but is slowly getting pissed she’s getting nowhere.
Brilliant_Object_548

Beat counter offer. Ask her to try out a large cross and /or star of david…
PariahZeal

There is a ‘phobe in this story, but it’s not you. NTA.
phyrsis

NTA

Report her before she reports you.

Conclusion

The core conflict lies between the OP’s clear boundary setting regarding personal religious expression and the roommate’s interpretation of this refusal as an act of religious intolerance. Despite the OP’s history of accommodation, the roommate has escalated the personal disagreement into a perceived public issue.

The central dilemma is how the OP can defend their personal autonomy and non-interest against an accusation that threatens their academic standing. Should the OP continue apologizing in hopes of reconciliation, or should they focus on formal documentation in case the university needs to be involved?

Categories Uncategorized