AITA for not allowing my 11-year-old daughter to have a boy sleep over our house?

Discover the birthday sleepover dilemma that left one mom questioning her choices! An unexpected request from a guest’s parent throws a kid’s party into a tailspin, leading to a surprising twist.
AITA for not allowing my 11-year-old daughter to have a boy sleep over our house?

As I said, my daughter’s 11 and her friend group ranges 11-12. It’s mainly girls but there is one boy that I have seen around.

She’s having a sleepover to celebrate her birthday this weekend. She invited the boy to the party but the plan was (or so I thought) that he would leave around 10 pm.

The boy’s mom called me last night to confirm that the boy (I’ll call him Tom) could sleep over. I said there must have been some miscommunication and I thought that she was picking up Tom at 10. I told her that if transportation was a problem my husband or I could drive Tom home.

Tom’s mom said that the issue was Tom wanted to stay over and would be let down if he had to go home. (Again, I don’t know why she thought he was sleeping over, since I made it clear on the invitation what was expected. We will have a couple other boys over who are the kids of family friends and they will also be leaving at 10 pm!).

It was a sort of awkward conversation to say the least. But she ended up saying she would come to pick up Tom after the party.

To be honest, even if I was inclined to have Tom sleep over, I doubt husband would go for it. But I’m starting to wonder if I did something wrong here?

Here’s how people reacted:

Rickerall77

Toms mom can fuck off!
SnausageFest

NTA, but I get both sides. I went to a few co-ed sleepovers when I was a kid. No big deal, there was always a parent in the room. It definitely happens so I get why she was confused and why he would be a bit disappointed if he’s been to other co-ed sleepovers before. But it’s your kid and your call to make.
QuinnReed

NTA. Kids change at very different rates. Some may still be very innocent at 11 others not so much.
Rivka333

NAH.
AliceChaine

NAH i’ve always had co-ed sleepovers from when I was a kid well into my teens (always platonic) as majority of my friends were guys. My parents were always cool with it, and we either just slept in the living room where they could easily check in or in separate rooms. So I can see why the other family may not see anything wrong with it.

It’s your house though, so your rules. You shouldn’t feel bad for enforcing them.

Fizzzure_

NTA, your the parent you make the rules.
yougottamovethisss

NAH – if they really are super close friends, I could understand why it would hurt his feelings if he wasn’t allowed to sleep over with the girls solely because of his sex. But I also get where you’re coming from, too.

​

You could have just had an adult stay close by or in the same room as them if that was a major concern, but I don’t think you were wrong to ask him to be picked up either. If his mother was cool with it, I think that is a good sign that she really just sees them as friends and actual children and not something to be overly concerned about.

abortionlasagna

NAH. Different families are gonna have different rules. Tom’s family may be okay with co-ed sleep overs, but you’re not and that’s perfectly okay for both of you.
I, myself, see no issue with co-ed sleep overs. But I totally understand cutting those off when gets get into the tween years when things start to get a little hormonal.
PalmTreeAmethyst

NTA- my daughter is the same age and has spent the night at a guy friends house along with 2 other girls though. Before she did I explained to her how it wasn’t typical, but I trusted them all and his parents, etc….I mean at that time they all still believed in Santa so we are talking some naive kids here.

But each family has the right to their own comfort level/rules.

CandyCigarettesxo

NTA, especially if you made it clear on the invitation that all boys must be picked up by 10 pm. The other mom probably thought she could guilt you into saying yes by calling you to confirm her son could stay the night and when you said no, responding by how “let down” he will be if he had to come home. That is not your issue and if she doesn’t like the rules, her son doesn’t have to come to the party at all. I have two girls, 13 and 6, and I will not entertain the idea of a coed sleepover at all. My house, my rules, period.
Manowar274

NAH, I can see why someone wouldn’t see a big deal because they are so young, but I also see how it would make someone uncomfortable, just a communication error is all.
derpplerp

NAH – simple misunderstanding. the lame dad fix would be to keep a parent in the room for the sleepover. I am a lame dad who would chaperone that way to keep everything square.
TakeItOrLeaveItIDC

NTA my kids won’t be having coed sleepovers until they’re in college.
happiieee

NTA. They are 11 years old. Although i’m sure they have no intentions on anything else but a sleepover, it is still a good rule to follow by. It is very awkward to have that kind of conversation with another parent, but your invitation said so. and what if you gave in and said he can sleepover? All of the other boys attending will want to stay over too. Not many parents would be happy about that. You did the right thing.
cautionjaniebites

NTA

​

Honestly, if my child had gone to a slumber party and I found out it was mixed, I’d be more than a little upset. Letting boys come over until 10:00 is generous enough and nobody should be upset that it’s not overnight.

Darkrixe

NTA
callistonire

NTA
When I was 11 people in my grade were getting into all sorts of sexual exploration and…other things. While not every 11 year old comes from a place like my demented home town, it’s good to set boundaries as a parent.

Given Tom’s mom response, I imagine they are still all sweet and innocent and don’t see the difference why a boy cant participate.

It has to happen at some point, sounds like you handled it pretty respectfully.

dingoperson2

NAH

_xNova

NTA. I had sleepovers where it was just me and my friend (I’m a guy and she’s a girl) when we were that age, but it was definitely not something everyone did, and looking back I’m shocked our parents allowed it
Lamenardo

NTA, you’re the parent, it’s your house, and it’s not unreasonable.

Conclusion

See how this parent navigated the unexpected situation and what happened when plans went awry. The story concludes with a decision that surprised everyone, proving that sometimes, things don’t go as planned.

Categories Uncategorized