
I am a male, in college and share a 3-bedroom apartment with 3 other people. I happen to live in the shared room with one other person. I don’t spend much time at home, but when I am there, I never make a mess, make noise, etc. However, I do often get home pretty late at night (12am-3am), almost every night I would say.
Sometimes, this is due to my job ending late, or me being at the library studying etc.. Others, it is because I am at a friend’s placing watching movies or such (never drinking so I am not coming home hammered and being noisy etc.) When I get home this late, I typically come in, shut the door, lie down and browse on my phone for a few minutes, and then go to sleep.
Recently, my roommate confronted me privately that I make too much noise and that this behavior is not ok with them.
I feel as though it’s my life and I can do what I want, and the way I act really isn’t that disturbing. I keep noise to a minimum and almost never notice my roommate waking up. Also, this has been going on pretty much all year, so I don’t exactly see why I was confronted only now.
I could see their complaint being valid in certain situations but, given the circumstances, I don’t think I am doing anything wrong. Am I the asshole here?
Conclusion
Was he in the wrong or did his roommate overreact? The internet is divided on this ‘Am I the Asshole’ dilemma.
Here’s how people reacted:
Maybe that coping would be to buy some ear plugs. Maybe it would be for the two of you to buy a strip of carpet and oil the door hinges.
Honestly, your roommate is lucky he doesn’t have someone who snores to share his room, which is something that very much happens in those circumstances. Roommates make noise, shifting in bed, getting up, talking in their sleep. He gets to go half the night without having to worry about yours and that has probably given him a false sense of what is normal.
Before I got one, my roommate woke me up nearly every morning and I woke him up almost every night. After we got one, it took a big mistake / large noise to wake each other up and we were so much happier with crazy schedules.
I feel as though it’s my life and I can do what I want, and the way I act really isn’t that disturbing
It’s not your *place*, so you can’t do what you want. And you don’t get to decide what you do that disturbs other people, that’s for someone else to inform you about, not vice versa.
When you share a room, particularly with a relative stranger, every party living in that room needs to make lots of sacrifices in order to co-habitate.
That being said, I don’t think you’re an asshole here, yet. But you need to try and be more mindful, or at least explain your situation, to your roommate.
And get your own place before you start thinking you can do whatever you want. I know your first rental unit is a really awesome taste of freedom, but you’re still sharing a bedroom with someone, and need to be conscious of that.
I imagine they get up early in the morning and you are still sleeping, right? And they make some noise… and you are not confronting them on their hours
You should minimize how late you stay out, within reason, and be as quiet as you can when you get home (you may not be being as quiet as you think you are), but there is only so much you can do. So to me, you’re slightly an asshole, but only slightly.
No way an asshole.
Yeah you are the asshole. You agreed to share a space with someone, and it looks like they respectfully asked you to show some consideration for them.
However I also totally sympathise with your roommate, I’m a light sleeper and it would drive me up the fucking wall if someone came in between 12 and 3am almost every night. It sounds like you may not be compatible roommates!