AITA for sitting on a man’s hand after he refused to remove it from the empty seat?

A pregnant woman’s commute takes an unexpected and explosive turn when a seemingly empty seat becomes the center of a bizarre public confrontation. Little did she know, a simple request to sit down would lead to a heated argument and a moment that left everyone on the bus stunned.
AITA for sitting on a man's hand after he refused to remove it from the empty seat?

Pretty sure I was an asshole here but we’ll see.

So, I, f30, am 8 months pregnant. I take public transport to work daily. I’m always exhausted cause I have to work extra time to be able to afford basic necessities. I take the bus to work everyday and often times it’s packed, but I get lucky enough when decent folks volunteer their seats for me.

Now I should mention that I don’t use my pregnancy as an excuse to get what I want, but people just offer me their places by themselves which is kind and sweet.

Wednesday, I get on the bus like usual but this time there’s one empty seat. I go to sit, but I find a guy in his business attire sitting there with his hand on the empty seat (sort of like resting it?). I say excuse me and ask him to remove his hand so I could sit, but he tells me the seat was “taken.” I ask by who and he says his hand.

Ngl….I laughed a little, but wasn’t feeling well so I ask him to remove it so I could sit, but he refuses again. Folks start staring. I tell him I’m tired and needed to sit, and he replies saying my pregnancy isn’t his problem. I had enough at this point, my legs were burning and my back was hurting, so I go ahead and sit on his hand.

He freaks out and tries to removes it quickly while shouting at me. He then starts arguing about how disrespectful I was to do this inappropriate thing, and in public no less. I argue back, ngl, but then he gets off after saying I was being inappropriate and disrespectful.

Everyone stares at me and I just sit there feeling a bit of shame about what happened.

I tell my husband about this incident and he wtf’d the entire time, then says that I did indeed act inappropriately and shouldn’t have made this guy uncomfortable by sitting on his hand like that. He tells me I fucked up and this was totally inappropriate despite me saying I was so tired of standing and was in desperate need to sit down.

AITA?

ETA several points- Like I said, I do get offered seats from others so I’m being treated well most of the time, but unfortunately run into some people who don’t do that. This guys seemed to be upset about something and then the argument probably made it worse.

I could’ve de-escalated by maybe talking to the driver? However, I’m pretty sure he didn’t pay for the seat just to put his hand on it (who does that?). Also, most of the passengers were younger folks that day. I normally would get a seat from older folks.

Here’s how people reacted:

JustASW

NTA. Though, I can’t believe you stole the seat from his only lover!
WholeCollection6454

NTA. I hope you farted.
gamerdarling

NTA. Seats are for butts, not hands. If you don’t want a butt on your hand keep it on your own seat.
MechanicMel84

NTA. I’ve been 8 months pregnant on public transportation and I 100% would have done exactly as you did. 🤷‍♀️ seriously, what did he expect? I’d love to see the AITA post for him…”AITA for not moving my hand, causing a pregnant lady to sit on it.”…
NoxWild

NTA. Your husband is wrong.

When I was in my 20s, 30s, and 40s I used the public bus system every day and *I know this kind of rider.* Sometimes they are snobs whose car is in the shop and they are *horrified* that they have to deal with a –*gasp*– STRANGER sitting next to them. Or they are touch-phobic. Or they think “I call dibs on two seats” should be honored on a crowded bus.

Good on you for sitting right down and not letting him get away with hogging two seats! Everybody on that bus was on your side!

trekkercorn

So, I do this thing with my cats where I sit down slowly if they’re in a space where I need to be, and I say “here comes the butt” and THEY MOVE.

This guy showed less intelligence than my cats. And a lot less compassion. NTA and also lol.

svmc80

Don’t know about you, but when my wife was 8m pregnant she could give two fucks what was appropriate. I backed her all they way and I back you up as well…. NTA
Sleepwalker0304

NTA.

His discomfort was his own damn fault. He tried to be an asshole and got pissed when you called him on it.

Frankly I’m kind of surprised more people didn’t publicly shame him for being a dick while he was doing it but you handled it well on your own.

Publius246

NTA.

Hell, he’s borderline the asshole for not offering his seat to a seriously pregnant woman. But not offering *his hand’s* seat? He and your husband are out of their damn minds.

SummitJunkie7

This isn’t about whether someone should give up their seat for a pregnant woman. Your pregnancy is irrelevant here. You don’t get two seats. Not for your bag, not to sprawl out or lay down, and not for your hand. He shouldn’t have tried to take up an extra seat, and he absolutely should’ve moved the first time you asked. I don’t know whether that completely justifies sitting on his hand, but it’s kinda unbelievable he still didn’t move his hand as it was clear you were sitting. He was playing some kinda weird power-trip chicken and he lost.

He’s the asshole.

ipainttherosesred

Not only NTA, but your husband sounds like one. And everyone around y’all during this incident need to learn basic respect and common decency for other human beings. I’d have done the same thing NOT pregnant, as I am a disabled person but you can’t visibly tell. I’m so sorry no one stuck up for you
Johoski

NTA.

You could have complained to the driver about a hostile passenger refusing to give you access to an available seat and gotten his ass thrown off the bus, but your way was more efficient. Props.

COMiles

NTA. But weaponizing your butt was inappropriate, you should have shot him in the hand like a civilized peron.
BriefHorror

NTA Play stupid games win stupid prizes
throwaboato

How dare you sit on his gf
ColoredGayngels

NTA, tf is wrong with this guy. Offering seats to the pregnant, injured, disabled, and elderly is a common courtesy without being a required rule. Moving your hand to your lap is not a burden nor worth arguing with someone over
liviwintergirl

NTA pregnancy aside how tf is this man gonna block an empty seat on a full public transit
if i had witnessed that i would have went off on him
Canning-mama-1998

NTA. The man was, as is your husband. Women have to put up with so much crap, Especially in transit. Manspreading, being felt up, etc. That guy was being a massive AH taking up a space – and almost every country I’ve been in has priority seating for pregnant women. So F him and any person who thinks what you did was wrong. What else were you supposed to do after you gas asked him several times to move his damn hand? Would your husband rather you have done nothing and potentially fallen when the bus made a quick stop?
dcm510

NTA. In fact, I’m proud – good for you! Stand up to bullies.
wheres_the_revolt

NTA and I love you

Conclusion

The pregnancy seat saga ends with a pregnant woman left questioning her actions after a public showdown, leaving onlookers and her husband pondering if she crossed a line. Was her desperate need to sit justified, or did her bold move on public transport ignite more outrage than relief?

Categories Uncategorized