AITA for giving my son a better life and spoiling him more than his siblings will ever get to be?

Nine years ago, a seemingly ordinary man’s life shattered. His wife, the one he vowed to cherish forever, betrayed him, walked away pregnant, and vanished into the arms of another. The legal system, in a twist of fate, sided with the new couple, leaving him to watch his son grow from afar. This wasn’t just a separation; it was a parental courtroom battle that left deep scars, a stark reminder of how quickly fortunes can change and how the definition of family can be redefined by circumstance.

He was left to pick up the pieces, build a new life, and find love again. Against all odds, he remarried, forging a new path and welcoming two more children into his life. But the shadow of the past lingered, a constant reminder of the son he couldn’t raise, the life he couldn’t provide. The universe, however, had a different plan, a surprising turn of events that would test his resolve and redefine the meaning of justice.

Little did anyone know that this wasn’t the end of the story, but merely the prologue to a tale of resilience, a testament to a father’s unwavering love, and a story that would unfold in ways no one could have predicted. The journey ahead was fraught with challenges, but it promised a reckoning, a chance for redemption, and a powerful conclusion that would leave everyone breathless.

AITA for giving my son a better life and spoiling him more than his siblings will ever get to be?

About 9 and a half years ago, my wife cheated on me, got pregnant, and left me for him. The courts gave them custody of our son because single dad vs family.

I’ve since gotten remarried and had a couple kids (7 and 5 and a half). My ex and her new man have also had 2 more kids.

Wife and I both work as engineers and have dang good salaries, to put it lightly. My ex and new husband haven’t ever done particularly well.

My ex-wife didn’t want me sending my son “lavish” gifts or taking him on the family vacations so her other siblings wouldn’t get too jealous and build resentment towards him (her words). Meanwhile, he was understandably (I feel) upset that he wasn’t getting as nice a life as my other kids were as he got older.

He asked to come live with me, and I said yes, I’d love to have him. My ex-wife said no. Thank God the courts sided with what my son wanted. Since moving in, everything’s gone fairly smoothly for us. My younger kids LOVE having their big brother around all the time; he loves them.

We still go on our vacations every January (though had I known how bad Rona was back then, I’d have probably held off this year). For his 16th birthday, he got a nice used Buick that he wanted. Since then, shit’s hit the fan with his mom/my ex, though.

She’s PISSED about how much he’s getting and getting to do, and keeps texting and calling both of us about how his younger siblings will never be able to get all he has, and it’s not fair, and now her kids are upset, and how I’m a horrible dad for forcing his siblings to resent him.

I finally told her I don’t care; I want my kids to have a good life, and if she wants an adulterer, hers would have a better life too.

Did I go too far there?

Here’s how people reacted:

cecilanode

My older brother just closed on his first house. I’m really happy for him, but it’s pretty unlikely with where I live and what I do that I’ll be able to do the same by the time I’m his age. I just won’t be able to have the same life he has.

This doesn’t mean that the solution is for him to give up on his house dreams. You don’t create equality by forcing people to have less so others don’t feel bad. Everyone ends up worse off that way. If you feel bad, you can create more good by thinking of little things he can share with the rest of his family—maybe a video game he can play with everyone or nice snacks he can share. Or you can do nothing at all.

It isn’t your job to keep other kids from envying your son. It’s your ex wife’s job to teach her kids that they can have more too by working hard and getting good jobs

NTA

s-mores

>my younger kids LOVE having their big brother around all the time, he loves them

This, above all other things, makes you NTA. You’re providing for your son and family, and that’s commendable. He’s also giving back by being a good big bro.

It’s not your responsibility what your ex thinks or does. You are not responsible for her emotions.

>calling both of us about how his younger siblings will never be able to get all he has

Uh, they will “never” move out, get their own cars and families? Also, what a sad and twisted thing to say, putting only value on material things.

>now her kids are upset

Not your problem.

>how im a horrible dad for forcing his siblings to resent him.

No, she’s doing that all by her lonesome.

Savbav

NTA. Her kids with her current partner aren’t your concern, and shouldn’t ever be. The only way they are going to be jealous or resentful about their half-brother is because she is teaching them to be. When you’re in a mixed family like yours, kids learn that different families are different. It doesn’t mean one parent loves them any more or less. Keep the texts for records, but don’t stop doing what you’re doing. He’s your kid, and he chose to live with you- probably because he saw through her toxicity. Encourage your son to keep his head up through her bullying. She is bullying you both, and is unacceptable.

I have two step-siblings (step-mom’s biological kids) who get everything from their dad. Even now that they’re adults. When we were teenagers in this new family situation, they got the newest phones available- Chocolates. Yeah, I was kind of envious. But, it stopped at, “man, I wish we could afford that!” No resentment was built, and I was not jealous. My dad and step-mom did well in teaching us that the different parents lead different lives and dynamics. There’s no reason for us kids to get angry about it. Although my step-mom was angry, I found out when I became an adult. because her ex’s sole purpose in buying these expensive things was to demonize her to her children, and try to buy their affection. Didn’t work out in the end. Step-siblings saw right through this manipulation and used it for their advantage.

It does not sound like you are manipulating your son with lavish things. You are treating him like you always would. Good on you for providing an amazing life for all your kids! Shame on your ex for trying to victimize herself and her kids.

opkc

NTA – Her kids are all under the age of 9 and they resent a 16-year-old for getting a car? It seems like the problem here is how your ex is raising her children.
Horror-mrs

NTA maybe your ex wife and her husband should think about improving their own lives than wanting your son to have less
HappyGreenGiraffe

NTA, your ex-wife is just jealous and trying to make you feel bad for your success. You love your kids and we are happy for them having a great dad. You ex-wifes new kids have nothing to do with you.
let_it_hang

NTA

Taking care of your kids makes you a bad guy?
Based on a cheaters logic maybe. Oh wait. You’re all good.

darkangle14

NTA why the fuck would you care about your ex wife and her kids tell her to mind her own business.
Twztdfmgtr

NTA – The title had me thinking you were going to be, but nope. Not your problem she can’t compare financially to you and provide what you are able to provide.
PillowWorldDreams

It’s posts like this that make me think “okay, you obviously know you’re NTA, we Redditors know you’re NTA, so if you want to tell your story just post it to /Entitledparents”
stp2395

NTA- you are allowed to give your son the best life possible. He is the one who does not have both his parents together, but his half-siblings have both mom and dad living together. So, I think its plain wrong for your ex to tell you not to give him gifts or lavish things just bc it would not be fair for the other kids .Your ex can use this time to explain to her kids that while life is not fair, thats life and we cant do anything about it- you have both parents together and your bro does not. Good job dad for sticking to your guns and being there for your son.

INFO- 1) does he still go to his mom’s house? 2) How would his siblings know what he gets at your house unless she puts it in their heads its not fair?

fruitynutcase

NTA

You treat your kids equally. Her kids with new husband are not your concern.

She should not poison her kids against your eldest. She could fully explain them why he gets more than them.

loser_rat

NTA good on you for taking care of your kids
dimsumplatter75

NTA. Imo, you should never have to feel bad about spoiling your kids (as long as it does not go to their heads). I would also add that it’s unfair on your son that your other kids benefit from your better quality of life, if you do not spoil him a little.

Your ex wife is in a tricky situation, but that is for her to deal with. She is an adult, and should figure out how to handle the situation at home.

612marion

NTA for giving him a good life
CrockpotHotshot

Only entitled ass people want to bring everyone else’s quality of life down in order to “level the playing field”. NTA – tell ex wife to pound sand. She/Cheater can get a better job if she wants what you have.
z3r0c00l_

NTA. She should have kept her fucking legs closed.

Adultery is a criminal act in 21 states. Granted it’s a petty law

But what gets me is the court saw it fit to grant custody to a cheating spouse. I guess I shouldn’t be surprised though.

While I don’t think her mom would try it as we have a cordial relationship, I too am a single dad, and the thought, or worry, of ending up in court someday and losing my rights to my child always lays in the back of my mind.

My child’s mother did nearly the exact same thing. She cheated on me with the guy for 6 months before she finally left. He was married with two kids. So the two of them destroyed two families. It’s obvious which persons are lacking morals, but I would bet my life that if we ended up in court, I would lose my daughter.

Money doesn’t mean anything at all. I make much, much more than both of them combined (I’m an IT Security Consultant and do freelance WebDev), but in the courts eyes, “a child needs his or her mother, even if that mother is morally corrupt and will not set good examples for the child”.

The hardest part of being a father is the chance the mother could walk away and take everything with her.

mattinva

NTA but feels more like a humble-brag AITA than an actual question.
wafflesareforever

INFO: How do her other kids even know what kind of life their big brother is leading? The car is probably obvious, but aside from that, who’s telling them?
Peachapatchi

I think what you meant to type was, “Am I the asshole because I’m rich and make more money than my cheating ex wife? Oh yeah, and we have a son too.”

Conclusion

The final act unfolded with a dramatic confrontation. The ex-wife, consumed by envy and resentment, unleashed a torrent of accusations, claiming the father was fostering jealousy among her younger children. Her pleas and threats, however, fell on deaf ears. The father, standing firm in his conviction, delivered a final, scathing retort, asserting his desire for all his children to have a good life and suggesting her current partner might provide that for her own.

This exchange marked a turning point, a definitive severance from the past and a clear declaration of priorities. The father’s words, though harsh, echoed a deep-seated commitment to his children’s well-being, a refusal to be manipulated by past betrayals or present insecurities. The narrative seemed to close on a note of righteous defiance, a father protecting his family’s future.

But did he go too far? The question hangs in the air, a lingering doubt about the line between protecting one’s own and inflicting pain upon another. The story concludes not with a simple resolution, but with a complex moral quandary, leaving the audience to ponder the true meaning of justice and the enduring consequences of choices made in the heat of battle. The ultimate outcome remains a subject of debate, a chilling reminder that sometimes, the most significant victories come at a profound personal cost.

Categories Uncategorized