‘WIBTA if I confronted my husband for crying in the bathroom after seeing his ex?’ UPDATED

In the whirlwind journey of love and unexpected encounters, stories like these often keep us on the edge of our seats. A young wife’s heart is filled with joy and anticipation, excitedly preparing for their first baby after a whirlwind romance that saw marriage just six months ago. Everything seemed perfect, like a fairy tale coming true, until an unexpected reunion threatened to turn their world upside down. With emotions running high and the future suddenly uncertain, what will this couple do when faced with a surprising blast from the past? The twists and turns of love often reveal unexpected truths—this story is no different.
'WIBTA if I confronted my husband for crying in the bathroom after seeing his ex?' UPDATED

My husband and I met 2 years ago. He proposed six months later and told me he knew I was the one when he met me and that he didn’t want to waste time or lose me. I was (still is) head over heels and agreed.

We have been married for 6 months and expecting our first baby.

Last weekend we bumped into his ex. They were together for 9 years but she ended the relationship when he didn’t take the relationship to the next level. When we got engaged and married my husband texted her to tell her and to apologize and talked about fate and how some things aren’t meant to be.

I remember asking him why, he said that he owed it to her that so she doesn’t hear it from other people and not be prepared. They broke up 3 years ago (edit not 4; it was October-December 2021; bad math).

She was pregnant and holding hands with a kid that could be 7 or 8 years old and she was with a man who was obviously her partner and they were very affectionate towards each other.

My husband said hi even though we could walk by unnoticed by them but he insisted to talk.

When we got home I heard him crying in the bathroom . Now he has been depressed and distant the whole week. I realized he must’ve written to her after we got home and he showed me his phone and yes he has.

Again apologized for what he did and told her that some things are not meant to be.

Would I be the ah if I confronted him about what’s going on? Why is he doing this

Here’s how people reacted:

UncleNedisDead

NTA, but it sounds like that cliche story.

Guy is happy with status quo and keeping the gf around for 9 years and while he says he’s open to the idea of marriage (to string her along), he believes it’s unnecessary and doesn’t actually make plans to get an engagement ring or pop the question. He just assumes if he runs the clock, she will be stuck with him for life

His Ex decides that she’s had enough of his placating words and realizes if she wants to get married and start a family, it can’t/won’t be with him. After she takes charge of her life and dumps him, he begs her to take him back and that he will give her the ring and wedding that she wanted, but it’s too little, too late. Curtains close on this relationship.

He takes a year or so to heal, and then finds you, who checks off most of his boxes and instead of risking the same thing happening again, he proposes to you in six months of dating and everything happens at warp speed because he has learned from his last serious relationship. Don’t leave it up to chance. Don’t string someone along.

Him bumping into his ex make him realize he still had feelings for the “one who got away”. That if he hadn’t been so stubborn and slow about getting a ring and making his ex happy, that could have been him.

> Again apologized for what he did and told her that some things are not meant to be.

He keeps telling himself that because it’s easier to blame fate and absolve himself about being a shit boyfriend who was wasting her time and ruined the relationship singlehandedly.

I’m glad his ex got her happy ending.

I’m sorry your marriage is starting to show cracks because your husband may be incapable of love and had a hidden agenda when marrying you. He might have married you to “prove”to his ex he could commit (like when he texted her about the engagement), rather than because of his deep and lasting love for you.

TrickInvite6296

it sounds like he got dumped because he refused to marry her, so he quickly jumped into a relationship with you + proposed INSANELY quickly to “prove” to her that she made a mistake. this is confirmed by the fact that he texted her to tell her.

you are a rebound. you were meant to be temporary to get his ex back

AlternativePrior9559

Unfortunately, OP he still sees this relationship as unfinished business. It sounds as though he’s still carrying a torch for her.

It’s not right to still be texting her now, you’re going to have to have a serious talk with him and make your decision from there.

UPDATEME

Typical_Internet_730

Sorry, but this is why I don’t like quick marriages. You haven’t had time to do any of the work necessary to determine compatibility. By investing time talking about hopes, dreams, and past relationships, you can learn who they really are. Seeing how he still won’t stop texting her, it’s obvious he isn’t over her. Texting her after the engagement would’ve been a red flag to me. Why? What good does it do YOUR relationship? It was for him to gauge her response, and her reply was going to determine his next move. I don’t see a path forward with him until he cuts all contact with her and attends couples therapy with you.
SuccotashCold7114

What a mess! Sorry you’re going through this.
I_luv_sloths

He still loves her. He texted her to “apologize” because he wanted her to know he is capable of taking it to the next level
itsrghtbehindmeisnit

Yikes. He very obviously has some feelings for her if he’s texting her while engaged, bent out of shape and depressed to the point of tears just seeing her moved on. I feel like by continously telling her that “some things just aren’t meant to be” he’s trying to convince himself it was something inevitable instead of his choice that he regrets.
Ladyughsalot1

Uh your dude sounds super cringey? 

Texting her to tell her he’s engaged….unnecessary but okay. But the whole “some things aren’t meant to be”? Come on. 

And then he repeats it now. 

I’d confront him and say listen- if he’s got regrets or hangups he needs to explore that **with a therapist** and he must promise that he will both do that *and stop texting her*. 

Also he’s being weirdly arrogant. She’s happy AF and he’s still apologizing?! lol she’s fine dude. She’s fine without him and he doesn’t like that. Doesn’t mean he’s hung up on her but he’s gotta get himself handled. 

JadedWarriorPrincess

Why is he still texting to apologise nearly a decade later? He’s overestimating how much she even needs to hear it. I think you need to demand answers from him, and you’re carrying his child he has no right to be depressed or distant over this. UpdateMe girl!
Altruistic_Key_1266

NTA-

I also love all the men in the comments who thinks this behavior is totally acceptable from a man who got another woman pregnant, and don’t recognize that his reaction to this situation is totally inappropriate, completely disrespects his wife, is cracking the foundation of his current relationship, and he is sowing seeds of mistrust and contempt with good reason. Nobody deserves to be second best, which is what he is showing she is to him.  

My dear- this is not ok. You deserve to be respected, as his wife and mother of his child. He should have dealt with these feeling before jumping headfirst into a relationship and getting you pregnant. You have to decide if you are ok being a placeholder for what could have been for him. 

vomcity

I’m sorry to say but this has been a performative relationship for him from the start. He’s tried to rush through all the markers of adulthood to prove to his ex he’s an adult. You just happened to be there and got caught up in his plan. The reactionary way he’s married you and gotten you pregnant is really concerning.
Able_Future_1680

No, you definitely would not be the asshole. There are a bunch of red flags here.
The fact that he sent her ANOTHER message about how they weren’t meant to be… Sounds like he still thinks they were meant to be. I’m not in his head, but I feel like he is fishing to see if she still has feelings like he obviously does. He felt the need to tell her you were pregnant/married, clearly she did not feel the same way.. ex. He had no clue she was a pregnant mom.

I think he saw her with a family and he feels like that should have been him.
Then move on to him proposing to you after 6 months, yikes. This is just a mess through and through. I suggest he starts therapy to work through his feelings.

I would try to speak with him openly and without judgement, otherwise he will most likely shut down. Your feelings matter though, you shouldn’t hide your pain to make him feel less shit about it.
I am sorry you are going through this. I would feel incredibly hurt to find out my “soul mate” felt the same way about someone else, like I’m a fill in since they screwed up the first time.

Denethorstomato92

NTA

I would lose a little bit of respect for him in this situation. He was the one that failed to move forward in his previous relationship. Now he’s got “one who got away” syndrome. He needs to be the mature one and be happy for his ex as she now has the family and life she wanted.

He needs to value what he has now right in front of him before he ruins another relationship/family.

Thisisthenextone

Sorry. You’re the rebound.

I’m not sure what people think will happen when they marry so early into knowing someone. You married before you even had two Valentine’s Days.

No-Astronomer6148

NTA.

The fact he 1/ texted her, 2/ cried and 3/ worst of all, has been distant is a red flag, it shows that he is NOT over her and he cannot even control those feelings and act normal towards you.

Frankly, it looks like he wishes he were still with her, and settled for you just because he couldn’t keep her.

4459691

OP
Your husband has issues. None of this is fair to you. You deserve someone who is all in with your marriage.

He was with a woman for 9 years. He did not want to marry her, but did not want to break up with her either. So he did not care that he was wasting her time. She decided that was not enough for her and left him. He is right because it wasn’t meant to be. For whatever reason, he was not able to win her back ( did he agree to marry her in the end but she said no too late?). Have you ever discussed it with him?

So instead of healing, he puts a bandage on the wound and has a rebound relationship. Were you aware of all of this before you married him?

Irishconundrum

My question is: why does he still have her number?
3bitaites

NTA. I think the current language for what you’re experiencing is “dream girl” vs. “placeholder”. You already know the answer to your own question, but you’re here to make sure you haven’t gone crazy. Which you definitely haven’t.

You’re right to feel hurt and suspicious. Sending those messages is so disrespectful. It’s just him trying to get her attention, anyway. And he’s trying to get an in with a married woman with children. Yikes.

By all means talk to him, but please do yourself a favor and put your own feelings above his tears. Don’t waste your time on someone who doesn’t actually love you, it’s time you can spend looking for someone who does or looking after yourself and your baby, when they arrive.

Senior_Entry_7616

He deff should of got some therapy after that relationship before proposing after 6 months, that’s insane you barely know each other
DruePNeck

You have every right to know what’s going on, but it’s all about if you approach it hostile or not
PerspectiveVarious93

I fucking hate weak men who try to reach out to women by acting like they are doing HER a favor. She probably wants to be left the fuck alone and not be bothered by your creepy husband every few years when the pang of regret gets too much for him and he just HAS to text her. Because SHE needs ANOTHER apology from him, right? Because she clearly hasn’t moved on and made a whole ass family in that time. I hope he wakes the fuck up because otherwise I’m seeing a dad who resents his own child for having the wrong mother.
Shdfx1

This man may be the type to always long for what he had, instead of appreciate what he has.

I’ll bet a couple of years from now, you’ll be strolling with your fiancé, who will be carrying your kid on his brawny shoulders, when you bump into your ex. He will walk away from his shocked new gf, and insist on chatting with you. Then he’ll keep sending you emails apologizing that it wasn’t meant to be. Then he’ll start calling you crying, begging for you to come back.

Good decision to move on.

SquirrelsNRaccoons

You may have married a “grass is always greener” guy. He’s never content with what he has.
Ok-Suspect-328

I hate liars. They lie to everyone even themselves until they have built a hell around themselves to torture thier loved ones with.
sammagee33

Jesus, just fucked all around. Not even TRYING to work on things. Not how I would do things…but you seem confident in your choice, so I guess that’s good.
Salt_Presentation790

He still.loves his ex and his world came crashing down when he saw her and saw what they could’ve had together.
Abject_Jump9617

It’s weird that he keeps wanting to apologize to his ex and tell her that some things were not meant to be. That was only needed to be said once, now it looks like he is just trying to convince himself.
MusicianLoose1908

Holy red flags! This guy asks to marry you and the first thing he does is call his ex? How old did you say those kids were? Are they his??! Now he’s in the bathroom crying over the woman he TRULY loves? You ARE READING THIS, right?

Girl, you better open your eyes and get off that crazy train.

roshidawg23

NTA. I’d just ask straight up.. Do you plan to resolve these unaddressed emotions in therapy and commit to me fully so we can both have peace of mind? I feel like that’s reasonable. If not.. I’m sorry but better now than years later you find this out.
Curious-Plastic1262

Nta – this would be enough for me to leave the relationship, I’m sorry he has not healed and you have to go through this. 
Electric-Fun

The fact that he keeps reaching out to her tells me he’s not over her. He keeps trying g to establish contact. He wants her attention. I’m curious what her responses have been. But you are NTA, OP.
Wise-Journalist3638

A big part of marriage is growing together. Seeing his ex is an opportunity to grow closer together. You have a husband that was open and vulnerable with you. If he did not love you, he would not have shared. My questions is for you. Would you rather reject him, throw him away and take on the life of a single mom? I am sorry, but what is the depth of your love for him? I do not encourage abusive situations – which this does nit appear to be. Why not work through it this and then see how overcoming this obstacle will bond you together forever and secure your position as his best friend in his life?
Cute-Profession9983

She’s the one who got away.
AreolaGrande_2222

Men marry the women in front of them, not the love of their lives
raj0kayshap

Sometimes you need a closure. I won’t blame him as he is not hiding from you. But this is also not appropriate. Please talk to him that you don’t like you reaching out to him being married to you.
darealyakim

Have you seen Sideways? Your husband is that guy.
Gloomy-Kale3332

That man is still in love with her.

This would break my heart if I was in your shoes, I don’t know how you move past this?

Admirable_Witness_82

NTA He may have loved her. But when someone can’t commit to you after nine damn years what is that love really worth. If you are both adults when you meet what was taking so long. I think being the one kicked to the curb is what’s gnawing at him. And knowing after all this time she still made the right decision.n
Adept_Ad_8504

Dang, OP, good for you. You are supposed to be #1, always.
AdditionalPudding968

The first text he sent to his ex was him trying to make his ex regret things. The second text was him telling her he regrets things. Im sure once OP leave him, he will text her something similar to the ex. He will never appreciate his current partner.
fakeprofilepic

Relationships are complicated. You can miss someone but also be with someone who is a much better fit. There are different kinds of love. As you get older (53f), you realize this.
Christianis4u

Reddit ruins another relationship.

I feel like this sub is undefeated.

Healthy_Avocado5044

Sounds like he never actually got over her.. And he rushed to marry you, cause he lost her for not putting a ring on it.. He tried to rush your relationship to where his previous one left off… It’s now backfiring on him..
indi50

People on reddit – myself included – have a lot of kneejerk reactions to things we read on here. It’s so easy to say, well he’s a jerk because he cried over another woman. But did he? Does he still love her or he’s just got some emotions he’s struggling with right now? And if it’s the latter, are you really going to throw away your marriage and the chance for a happy home with both parents for your child, without even trying to find out?

I read the comment you said shared your feelings. So he “learned his lesson” and didn’t string you along because he didn’t want to lose you.” And you say love him like crazy. But because he may have some unresolved feelings for an ex, you’re going to dump him when you’re expecting a baby. Without even trying to work through anything? Without trying to figure out if maybe it was just unexpected feelings and past regrets – rather than still loving her? Just….you’re done because he’s human and you might not be the center of the universe for a minute or two? But maybe you would be again once things settle down??

I’ve recently cried about my broken marriage (over almost 20 years ago) and wondered if things could have been different. But I have absolutely zero romantic feelings or love for my ex. If I could go back, I would have left him sooner even though I loved him madly for a long time. Crying “over another person” is not always because you miss that person or want them in your life, there are lot of mixed emotions about a lot of things connected to the relationship.

If he had actually loved her – or at least wanted a life with her, he would have proposed when he had the chance. He proposed to you right away. Unless you have some other reason to think he doesn’t love you or would rather be with her, then, please….take some time before you make a decision that will affect the rest of your life – and your child’s.

JanaAlya

NTA

Something seems off, but then I’m usually pretty suspicious by nature and training. Maybe a talk rather than outright confrontation. You are right to at least wonder and to need an explanation. The timing for this is pretty FUBAR, but it may be nothing more than some unresolved hurt about the way things ended between them.

BTW, he’s probably always going to love her, because that’s how love usually works. That alone isn’t something to be concerned with, so long as he doesn’t fixate on that.

Then_Barracuda6403

Voice your feelings and keep communication very open. Tell him your feelings and don’t hold anything back. Keep this through your entire relationship and ALWAYS be honest. You are the rebound and rebounds don’t normally last. He is very wrong to be doing this to you for sure. He should not have committed before resolving his issues.
beaxtrix_sansan

NTA. I just want to send a hug. Your husband is just selfish!
Original_Clerk2916

I’m just a bit confused as to why you decided to leave
bellaboks

NTA this shows you he is still in love with her ! I would politely dip out of this relationship and go find yourself someone that is 100% into you

Conclusion

As the dust settled and the encounter became just a fleeting moment of the past, this young couple learned a valuable lesson about trust, forgiveness, and the unpredictability of life’s surprises. Their story highlights how love can withstand unexpected bumps, even when faced with past flames and lingering memories. Now, as they stand on the brink of parenthood, they’re reminded that every challenge can be a stepping stone to a stronger bond. In the end, true love isn’t about avoiding complications but navigating them together — stronger, wiser, and more united than ever before. Who knows what the future holds, but one thing’s certain: their story is just getting started.

Categories Uncategorized