‘AITA for not letting my daughter be around her mother?’ UPDATED

In the world of family relationships, every decision can lead to unexpected surprises. When a parent decided to bridge the gap between their daughter and a new acquaintance named Ellie, no one knew exactly what to expect. Would this encounter bring joy, understanding, or awkward tension? The story chronicles a simple but heartfelt attempt to foster connection and see where it might lead. Sometimes, the smallest gestures can turn into significant moments that reshape relationships forever.

As plans were made and hopes set high, both the parent and daughter were cautiously optimistic about the upcoming meeting. The evening was filled with anticipation—would Ellie’s friendly demeanor soften any doubts? Could this be the beginning of a new friendship, or would old fears and misunderstandings overshadow the hope of something better?

What unfolded next was a blend of warmth, genuine moments, and unexpected revelations. It’s a reminder that sometimes, opening the door to new relationships requires courage, patience, and a willingness to see the good in others. The ending of this story strikes a balance between resolution and new beginnings, leaving us pondering the true power of kindness and understanding in family matters.

'AITA for not letting my daughter be around her mother?' UPDATED

I thought I’d give an update. I decided to talk to my daughter and ask what she thought about meeting Ellie. She said she’d like to meet her, so we arranged to meet at a restaurant.

Ellie was cordial and asked my daughter about her favorite things to do, school, and her friends. My daughter even asked Ellie if she has any other kids, and Ellie replied, “Yes, sweetie!

You have two half-brothers.”

After our meeting, Ellie texted me to say thanks and asked if she could start seeing my daughter on a set schedule. I told her I wanted to take things slowly. Then she said, “Before we set anything up, maybe we should discuss child support for the time she’ll be with me.” I thought she was joking.

I replied, “I have full custody. I’m not paying you to visit your own child!” She got angry, saying, “You’re still the same selfish jerk as before! I have two other kids and am raising them alone!

Now I finally connect with my daughter, and you’re being a deadbeat.”

At first, I thought it was a prank, but it turns out she has serious money problems. It seems she was hoping to get shared custody so I’d start paying her, essentially to babysit her own daughter.

I told her if that was her plan, she wouldn’t get a dime from me. She kept insulting me and eventually blocked me.

Since then, my daughter has asked several times what happened to Ellie. I just told her that Ellie must be busy and that if she contacts me, I’ll let her know. Ellie is banned from ever contacting my daughter until she an adult and decide for herself

Here’s how people reacted:

FaraSha_Au

What a miserable excuse for a human being.
Crafty_Special_7052

Wow she’s crazy. Also, if she wanted shared custody she would need to go through the courts. At least now you know why she tried to get back in your life. She wanted to use you for money. Honestly she should be paying you child support.
atmasabr

Wow.

Despite going against everyone’s advice (mine included), I think you did things the right way by seeking your daughter’s opinion and proceeding with caution.

Alas, motherhood has made Ellie regress. She has gotten *worse* at manipulation and plotting. Maybe she contracted the Terrible Twos from her children: “I wannit NOW!”

SnooWords4839

Money, they only reason she wants to be a mother. What a cunt.
Nightwish1976

What a human excrement.
RedneckDebutante

You’re going to need a licensed child therapist to help you explain this to Ellie. This is far to delicate to do alone.
Away-Understanding34

Ugh I am so sorry for you and your daughter. Elle is really shitty for her ulterior motives and involving your poor daughter. I would be on alert though. I’m not sure she’s done trying to get money from you. 
GoddessfromCyprus

If she wants ‘shared custody’ does she realise that she would, according to the way she’s thinking, have to pay you when you have your daughter and in that event, you cancel each other out?
Significant_Planter

The irony that she tampered with condoms to get pregnant when she knew you didn’t want that, to try to force you into a relationship you didn’t want and she’s going to call you selfish? LMAO 

The whole reason you’re even in this conversation is because shes SO selfish! Unreal! Keep your daughter away from her at all costs. You don’t want her to turn out like her egg donor. 

fetchinbobo66

Has she been paying you child support all of these years ?
Fantastic-Corner-605

I think you have a case for suing her for child support.
Mother_Search3350

What a monumental AH. You need to keep that woman away from your daughter.  The emotional damage she is going to do to her will take years of therapy to undo.  When she is older and an adult and is mature enough to deal with the fact that she has a crappy egg donor for a mom, she will decide what relationship she wants have with her. 

 Right now, you need to protect your daughter from that emotional vampire and deadbeat. 

Next time she contacts you, tell her she owes YOU 7 years of back child support and you will be suing her for it of she doesn’t back off and stop harassing you 

DawnShakhar

I’m sad for your daughter. She would like to have a mother, but her bio-mother is a bitch who only wanted to use her for money. Your daughter is better off without her.

You should consider having some female influence in your daughter’s life. Perhaps a friend or relative could agree to do some of the “female” things with her. But definitely not this poor excuse of a mother.

CompanyHead689

File for child support since you have full custody
wlfwrtr

Make sure Ellie can only talk to you over text message in the future. Don’t reply to any that aren’t about your daughter. Screenshot everything.
prosperosniece

It may be time to get a lawyer.
SerenityLunaMay

Honestly, you never should have let her meet your daughter. You should have met her one on one. Now you know for future discussions. Also, never ever discuss her seeing your daughter before talking to a lawyer first. You could screw your custody doing that.
el_grande_ricardo

NTA, but you need to be more honest with your daughter. Let her know you found out Ellie had some hidden motives for coming around now, and that causes you not to trust her around the most precious thing in your life.

If you don’t, Ellie will find a way to sneak in and convince your daughter that YOU are the bad guy and kept sweet, innocent Ellie away from her beloved daughter.

jdbtensai

Disgusting woman.
Talk_aboutlife

I’m sorry your ex is such a jackass. I’m very sorry for your daughter. This is one of the saddest post I’ve read yet! Praying for you & your daughter.
MaryEFriendly

Wow. She is a disgusting person. She has no interest in your daughter and just sees her as a money grab. 
Dana07620

The other shoe dropped. You should have asked her about the years of child support that she owes you. But I know you don’t care about that.

You just want this shit hole of an egg donor out of your daughter’s life.

But some day you do owe your daughter the truth about what happened. Save this thread. Or write it in a letter. Or make a recording. Because one day Ellie is going to tell your daughter a bunch of lies about this and when you tell your daughter what happened, Elllie will say you’re lying. This will be proof that you’re not.

2dogslife

Save all her communications into a folder in case she somehow finds a way to bring things to court.

Your daughter doesn’t “need” a female influence. Plenty of kids do just fine with a single parent. There are, I am certain, teachers, neighbors, the mothers of friends, possibly family members, who are around to model behaviors.

BlueDragon203114

Sounds like my cousin and his ex she left him with a kid that he found out wasn’t his after he was born and he was already invested and loved the kid so he kept him
Critical-Bank5269

A leopard doesn’t change its spots….
Maleficent_Pay_4154

I’m sorry this happened to your daughter . Please keep protecting her

Edited as I mixed the names up

Strangley_unstrange

I can promise if she even tries to get child support from you your lawyer is going to ask for 7 years back support for taking care of Ellie which will likely cancel out Any CS she would recieve from you
Dream_luna

How horrid is that person in human skin? I’m sorry for your daughter but the biggest mistake you can make is to lie to her, tell her truth so that she is aware of what’s really going on and if she comes back again she won’t be able to fill her head with lies. NTA!
Atarashii_Hinode

I’m no expert, but I belive you should tell the truth to your daughter. She’s nine, she’s already old enough to understand somethings. If you don’t tell the truth to her, Ellie might someday show up to her and tell her that you were the one that prevented her from seeing your daughter and this might ruin the trust she has on you.
SweetBekki

Ever thought that maybe your ex doesn’t have any interest in her own daughter? Sounds like she only came back into her life to ask for money.
DivineTarot

Damn, what a trash woman. She really deluded herself into thinking she could get child support through her daughter, and exploited the poor girls desire for a maternal connection to try for this. What an absolute disgusting piece of work.
Amber22886

You should go after her for child support! What a sorry excuse for a mother she is! I’m glad you decided to step up and take care of her. Best of luck to you both!
senjisilly

Updateme!
TemporaryThink9300

What a vulture of a woman, she acts like a starved scavenger circling her own daughter, to rip a piece of flesh out of her daughter’s longing heart for her mother’s love, ugh, makes me sick. 😔
PandoraElf

Holy hell!!!! That women has some damn nerve, using a child like an ATM. I feel for her, it was better when she was gone and now she has to think what did i do wrong?, why am i not enough for my mom? You really need to tell her what happened, maybe in a therapy setting.
DatguyMalcolm

what a horrible person she is

I bet the two other kids were from her doing a similar thing to whoever and they just ghosted her

People like her should not have kids

great-nanato5

Your daughter deserves the truth. If she finds out from someone else, she will resent it. Just tell her that Ellie only wants money from you and that her visitation will be complicated if she shows up. You have custody, so technically, she should pay you. That will stop things quickly. Do not lie to your daughter. She is old enough to understand what’s happening. Also, do not give up full custody, or your ex will tell her all kinds of lies. She has already said she would, so talk to your daughter first.
StrykerC13

Do make sure to be honest with the kid when she is older unless you want to find yourself in the same situation as another father of his daughter cutting him off and then coming back when she Finally realized her mom only wanted to live with her so she’d pay for things.
Crafty-Difference-36

Updateme
Super_Reading2048

Wow 1 I hope you saved those texts 2 get a lawyer
Jazzlike-Bird-3192

That’s really sad. I’m very sorry for your daughter. 💔
TickityTickityBoom

NTA did you get child support from her in the last 7 years? I’d not, perhaps apply for back support.
MelG146

You should have filed for child support yourself years ago.
penguin_cat33

Sounds like she tried to trap at least one, probably two, other men with babies and they ditched her so she tried to circle back around to the first person she screwed over to get money to bail her out without even the slightest care about what that would do to your daughter. She’s an evil, selfish human being. Anyone who uses children like that deserves the worst.
Flimsy-Call-3996

NTA.
winterworld561

So she actually had no interest in reconnecting with her daughter, she just wanted money. Hopefully she won’t come back now that she knows she won’t get anything from you. The other kids she has are probably from her messing with condoms again and those dads did a runner when they found out what she did. She’s a miserable sad sack excuse of a human. Speak with a lawyer and find out what you can do to make sure Ellie never gets near your daughter again.
laughter_corgis

NTA. Screen shot those messages and give them to a lawyer.
You are a good Dad!
dublos

> Then she said, “Before we set anything up, maybe we should discuss child support for the time she’ll be with me.” 

If you were to file for child support, she’d have 9 years of back payments to make before anything were to happen going forward.

evilcj925

Not only is she a shit person, Ellie is also pretty dumb. She doesn’t seem to understand that in order to get child support, she would have to have the majoraity custody. She would also have to pay any child support from the past.

Your doing the right thing keeping her away from your daughter.

hideme21

Next time she contacts you. Tell her you will agree to split custody if you go through legal channels. And discuss back pay on the child support for the last 9years.
Unable_Maintenance73

Wow. Contact an attorney and make sure you have all of your ducks in a row. This sorry excuse of a human will undoubtedly start some leal child support chit with you. It is better to be safe and prepared than sorry.
Pure_Cat2736

The fine print comes out! Nah NTA!
Material_Cellist4133

Make sure you have texts of her just wanting to be in your daughter’s life just for child support.

Also, you could take this opportunity to file child support for the past several years she hasn’t paid.

dunno0019

Just curious: has she paid any child support in all the years she was gone?
Zonian4ever

Updateme
longndfat

what a terrible human Ellie is who considered her daughter only as an ATM.. my heart goes out for your daughter… she must have been excited to meet her mother finally and then suddenly she is again out of touch.
CocoaAlmondsRock

Document the hell out of this in case she comes sniffing back with a different plan.
KingSuperJon

Um if you have full custody of her daughter, why haven’t you sued for child support? Has she signed away her parental rights? If not, she owes you(r daughter) child support. Years of it.
exhaustedgoatmom

Keep everything as evidence just incase your ex tries to pull bs.
JunePlum79

What a disgusting excuse for a mother. You did the right thing here.
Ok-Nose42

I would recommend seeing child psychologist to see how much you should express to her about her mom for right dialogue.
DetroitSmash-8701

NTA. That said, the more you keep quiet, the more you are setting yourself up and your daughter for failure. You should be in Defcon 5 mode at this point. Your daughter needs to know the truth, her school needs to be put on notice, law enforcement/family court needs reports filed as well. It is better for yourself and your daughter for you to be proactive and in front of this impending shitstorm that’s on its way.
Cuddle_RedBlue0923

Wow, what a miserable excuse for a human.
Ok-Reply9552

You could tell your daughter the truth. Her mother only wants to connect with her so she’ll get paid. Not telling her the truth isn’t the right thing to do here.
Dr_Biggie

Shouldn’t this woman, who gave birth to your daughter and then left her alone with you as a toddler, be paying you child support to you for raising the child you both had together over the last seven years? After pulling a stunt like she just did, at the expense of your daughter’s feelings, I hope that you go after her for future and past child support payments. She deserves to be held accountable for what she is trying to do. She has minimal interest in building a relationship with her daughter and only wants some financial benefit while probably using her daughter to care for her other young children so that she can have a break, since it’s so difficult being a single mother. I use a bit of sarcasm in the last part of my statement only because I suspect that is the logic she will use to justify her actions.

I believe the request of the mother of your child is absolutely vile, and I feel terrible for the little girl and I am thankful that she has you to support, love, and care for her.

ReaderReacting

So sad that you have to go through this. Ellie doesn’t seem to know how custody and support works. You could be requesting support from her (and if push comes to shove you should!)

I think it’s great, though, that you gave your daughter a choice. I know it didn’t end well, but it will mean something to her in the future!

I told my kinship child that unfortunately some people don’t have the capacity to be a real parent. That it has nothing to do with her she is wonderful! And it doesn’t even have to do with what her parent a want or feel. They just don’t have the capacity to be a parent. Kind of like an elephant doesn’t have the capacity to climb a tree. It doesn’t meant they don’t love the or don’t want to climb the tree, they just can’t do it.

Dont-Blame-Me333

NTA but danger 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩 You know who else wants money for children? S3x traffickers. Never let that female anywhere near your daughter.
Odd-Meeting1880

I agree. however. your daughter may hate you for this later..

but , do what you gotta do for your kid.

GentlemanlyAdvice

Oh my god. Please let this be fake.

She got her daughter’s hopes up for a mommy in order to shake you down??

What a complete scumbag.

AccordingToWhom1982

As your daughter gets older, you need to start telling her the truth in an age appropriate way. Otherwise, one day she might reconnect with Ellie who could spin a story that you kept her away from your daughter.
Left-Ad-2496

Ha! of course there was a catch. 💵💵

Dude, lawyer up. Ellie is only just starting. Make sure she doesn’t get any shared custody.

Commander-Rial

Hopefully you have everything documented. Screenshots, emails, etc… you’re keeping the real reason “Elle” is gone from your daughter – and I won’t judge that either right or wrong – but when your daughter is an adult, or maybe even while she’s still a teen, she may ask questions. Or worse, Elle will find a way to reach your daughter with her (probably lie filled) version of events. You’re going to want that documentation to prove your side of events because between the back and forth of you not wanting her and then Elle not wanting her, your daughter might (rightfully) end up confused on who to believe or support.
Rezolution20

Well the good part is that she showed her true intentions from jump. It would have been worse had she started a relationship with your daughter, then did the extortion. I would think that a court would let you completely get rid of her by stripping her of any parental rights, and then when your daughter is older, if she wants to seek out a relationship she could do so. I’m really hoping that your daughter chooses to never have contact though, because I could see this woman trying to guilt your daughter into giving her money with sob stories. Keep her in therapy and she’ll get the help she needs to deal with this woman dipping back into her life, only to leave again.
gspyda

you both ATAH

Conclusion

In the end, this story reminds us that taking the risk to connect with others, especially family, can lead to surprising and heartwarming results. What started out as a simple meeting grew into a moment of genuine understanding, showing that sometimes, all it takes is a little openness and kindness to turn unfamiliar faces into friends. The tale leaves us hopeful that healing and harmony are possible, even in the most delicate family situations.

The young daughter’s willingness to meet Ellie paved the way for a gentle, friendly encounter that could serve as a stepping stone toward stronger bonds. The story’s conclusion is a testament to the fact that openness, patience, and sincere effort can transform relationships and bring families closer together. As you reflect on this story, remember that every small act of kindness has the potential to make a lasting impact.

So, could this be the start of something beautiful? Only time will tell. But one thing is certain: when families choose understanding over assumptions, they open the door to new possibilities and a future filled with hope and harmony.

Categories Uncategorized