
My husband and I share a Netflix account with the Basic Plan (only one screen) and we have an understanding that if one of us is watching something, we let them be and do something else.
Recently, my SIL (who isn’t very pleasant and whom I don’t get along with) asked my husband for Netflix account details. My husband informed me that he would be sharing the login details.
I thought it was a one time thing and was ok with it. But it so happened that every time I sat down to watch, I couldn’t because she was using it. She made profile for herself as well.
Now the catch is, she lives in Europe and I live in Asia so I guess Netflix is cheaper here? Idk.
I got irritated the third time I sat down to watch and couldn’t because she was using it. When I told my husband this, he told me that she hasn’t used it in two weeks. So I assumed someone else is leaching off of me.
I signed out of all devices and then deleted her profile.
And now apparently she is pissed and my husband is pissed that I was being so petty. She now wants my husband to create a new account for her from our country so she can use it in her country.
I know I was petty, but asshole?
Conclusion
In the end, this story serves as a reminder that even the simplest agreements can become complicated when family politics come into play. The line between generosity and boundaries is often blurred, especially when it involves shared accounts and delicate family relationships. The couple’s decision to stand firm on their policies prevented further complications and showed the importance of clear communication. Sometimes, denying access to a shared resource like Netflix isn’t just about the service — it’s about respecting your own boundaries and maintaining peace in your personal life. The episode leaves us wondering: how far should we go to keep the peace, and when is it time to draw the line? In the world of family and streaming, it’s all about finding a balance that keeps everyone happy without sacrificing your own comfort. Remember, no matter how small, setting boundaries can save you from bigger issues down the road.
Here’s how people reacted:
She literally asking for you to pay for her Netflix. The basic one here is €10. How much cheaper could yours be? She can pay for it herself.
I feel like all those saying YTA or ESH are currently mooching off someone else’s streaming service.
The last thing I had to put my foot down about was the phone charger I keep stashed at work. I finally drew the line when my phone would start getting unplugged in the middle of a recharge. Now nobody is using the fucker but me. The offending co-worker was all pissed about it, but I have no problem being the bad guy in your narrative because your freeloading ass went from appreciation to entitlement. Once you cross that line, you’re done.
Back to your story, NTA if the story is true based on the above reason. It’s a correct action anyway before they start an IP ban on your country
Ask him why he’s upset with you. Remind him that it was HIM that told you she wasn’t watching. So what else were you to conclude other than someone was using that account to steal your netflix? Ask him if you were supposed to just NOT watch Netflix while some hacker or whoever out there just took over your account.
Tell that ungrateful nasty freeloader to piss off and pay for her own netflix account
Why do you pay for her ? If she’s minor, she has parents to pay for. If she’s an adult, she can pay for Netflix.
Not sure why your husband is pissed, he said she wasn’t using it.
But why can’t your husband pay for a more expensive package. I still wonder how there is only one screen, even with my with ads I get two.
I had a similar issue, except it was my sister. Either we couldn’t watch anything because her and her ex-husband were using it or, we started watching something and they would kick us off.
Needless to say, I kicked them off and changed the password.
And didn’t he say that she hadn’t been using it? So why is she complaining? And why can’t she pay for her own account? She sounds very entitled
I would be concerned as to why your husband is taking your SIL side and not yours.
Not to mention: Sharing across CONTINENTS?! I’m surprised Netflix didn’t intervene already! But that’s irrelevant. You don’t owe her anything. If ANYTHING, if you want to be super nice, upgrade to the 2-screen plan and make her pay the difference. If she’s unwilling… she can eat a bowl of you know whats.
Your husband is the AH too for getting pissed.
In your case, there was evidence that she shared the password with someone else without your permission, which is a breach of privacy AND can get you in trouble with Netflix. If your husband wants to risk it HE can pay for her Netflix on a separate account.
Why would you be the asshole? Its your money. They are just mooching/leeching on your wallet.
NTA
NTA.
Because you haven’t talked to her, only your husband has?
Same dude who told you she wasn’t using it?
You sure it’s his sister…?
Nah, keep dumping those extra accounts, and boot any out of household users anytime you wanna use your own netflix account – and change the password every time too.
He’s gonna get your account suspended if he keeps giving her the password…
Different countries have different content. So the financial side of things could have been one reason or it is just the content you are getting versus what she is getting in her country.
Either way, she is in the wrong and your husband too.
NTA
if your sil wants to watch netflix she should afford the membership
Whenever I try shenanigans like that (I.e. setting up an account and or the payment, I will fully offer the pay in advance the subscription fee AND extra for just the hassle…)
And she could have gotten your account banned. Streaming services get cranky when folks are literally several countries away from each other
You want to use the service that you pay for.
You did nothing wrong here, imo.
You asked. The answer was essentially – some stranger is accessing your Netflix. You were smart to take action.
SIL can pay for her own account or to upgrade yours to multiple screens.
SIL’s use of your Netflix acct was preventing you from using it.
Your husband also confirmed (truthfully or not) that SIL was not using the account.
You acted normally and secured your acct.
Your sister in law is technically stealing services. Your husband is either felusional or permitting it.
Netflix will eventually catch on and either terminate the SIL for being out of continent where the account is registered, or they will start to charge expensive fees for 2 accounts.
So unless hubby is paying for his sister’s, get her off and keep her off. If she stays on, get 2 screen accounts.
Edit: Per the comments you can share across countries but still have to pay extra.
Also your not married or owe anything to his sister! She claimed she hadn’t used it and sounded like you wanted to make sure someone also wasn’t using your info! She can pay for her own or if your husband wants to be a kiss ass he can pay for it which i think is stupid!!
Or he can upgrade it and she needs to split costs with you guys . That’s not fair you can’t even use your own thing!!
She can create her own account. It’s not like it’s thousands of dollars a month.
I’d expect the same from anyone else I was mooching off of!
Your SIL is not entitled to a subscription you pay for. If you’re uneasy about other people having access to your account without consent, it is completely within your right to revoke access.
You shouldn’t be sharing your nextflix account with anyone. The IP address for your SIL is different than yours, and multiple logins will be shown. Your SIL can get her own.
They count as extra households as they aren’t home each month to log in devices at home at my IP address (that they use elsewhere at uni).
So your SIL shouldn’t be using your account in a different country as not a part of your household- Netflix will catch on. They are already cracking down.
Besides that, you have an only one user at a time Netflix account.
You pay for it equally with your husband. So your viewing takes precedence, even IF you were allowed to share either other households (which you aren’t)
I don’t blame you for logging out all other devices, so you can watch the streaming service you pay for. I would have done so too. SIL is out of order here to even slightly complain!!
Your sister can buy her own Netflix account. And she should. You are 100% right to watch what you want to watch on Netflix on your paid for account and log out anyone mooching off of you to prevent that. Your husband is wrong. You are more important here.
The only reason that she would want an account in a different country is because she probably gets different programming, but that’s still not a you problem, and you shouldn’t have to pay for it.
You pay for it. It’s your account to do what you will.
You agreed to share with your hubby, you didn’t agree to anything else. If the goalposts are moved you’re allowed to say you don’t want to play anymore.
Even if you did sign out of all devices there’s a high chance it wasn’t you and it’s them not allowing multiple users internationally.
Tell your husband that you said yes as a one off and that you won’t do it as a long term or regular thing as it’s breaking the terms of use and Netflix could close your account for breaching the terms.